Polo Black vs Polo Double Black Cologne Comparison

For this fragrance comparison, I want to take a closer look at two scents from the house of Ralph Lauren, Polo Black and its flanker Double Black. It is interesting that with a name like Black, that the original of the two was much more of a fruity fragrance than anything dark. Double Black retained a piece of Polo Black but took things in a different direction.

Now, which one smells better? Which performs better? When should they be worn? Continue below for the complete analysis.

---

Polo Black vs. Double Black

Polo Black Tale of the Tape

Notes include:  mango, sandalwood, tonka bean, tangerine, sage, lemon, patchouli

Click here to try: Polo Black by Ralph Lauren for Men – 4.2 Ounce EDT Spray

My review: Polo Black Review

---

Polo Double Black Tale of the Tape

Notes include: coffee, mango, juniper berry, nutmeg, cardamom, pepper, woods

Click here to try: Polo Double Black by Ralph Lauren for Men, Eau De Toilette Natural Spray, 4.2 Ounce

Read my Polo Double Black Review

---

Opening

From the opening smell, it becomes clear that while these two colognes are related, they provide completely distinct experiences from one another. Polo Black is noticeably fruity from the start.

Now, this isn’t a very sweet type of fruity smell (think dried fruit pieces), the mango note is prominent from the get go but it does have a spicier profile at the start.

Double Black also contains the mango note, though, it is a background player and from the start it is a spicy/smooth blend of pepper and coffee. Polo Black also has citrus notes which gives it that extra bit of something, that sets it apart at the opening.

Edge: Black (slightly)

---

Projection

Both of these scents are moderate and while they do a decent job of projecting at the start, it isn’t a sustained output throughout the wear. I think due to the blend of the tonka bean, coffee, and pepper, that Double Black might have a slight edge in this respect.

At least that’s the case for the first hour or two. If Double Black doesn’t last on your skin, Polo Black will sustain for longer. At the peak? Double Black.

Edge: Double Black

---

Longevity

With a name like Double Black, you’d think that this fragrance would be all about longevity. It’s not. I tend to get 4-5 hours of wear out of Double Black, which is disappointing.

I really expected more from Double Black. The name makes you think that it’s going to be something much stronger and longer lasting. Nope. Not a lot of longevity, even with its bolder opening act.

Polo Black is usually better in this regard. Sometimes, it will drop off at 5 hours, but it will go further in most cases. Maybe 6-7.

Edge: Black (slightly)

---

Versatility

Both scents are safe and very nice choices for casual wear. I think the difference comes into the seasonal use of each. Double Black is well suited for fall/winter type of wear.

Meanwhile, Polo Black is almost like a year round scent, in that, it performs quite nicely in each…including the warmth of summer.

Edge: Black

---

Overall Scent

I really warmed up to Double Black more and more, as I got through my sample of it. I’m a fan of tonka bean scents and this one also has a gourmand edge with the coffee, a spice with pepper, and enough sweetness to fully round out the scent. I like wearing Double Black.

However, Polo Black is a little bit better smelling and my opinion and has enough of an edge performance wise to merit a victory.

Its fruity notes are really unique and well done plus it has a woodsy heart, that helps it maintain a masculine vibe.

Neither one hits it completely out of the park. Though, Polo Black is a very good cologne. I wish the sillage and longevity was better, but it’s not terrible, and it smells very nice.

Update: Double Black has been discontinued for a while now. Not a big loss, even if it could’ve been really nice with some weight behind it. So, you’ll have to go with the still available Polo Black, unless you want to spend a ton of money for a not as good cologne.

Winner: Polo Black