Polo Black by Ralph Lauren

For my review today, I want to tackle Polo Black by Ralph Lauren. This men’s cologne was released in 2005 and has enjoyed some decent popularity ever since. It spawned one flanker, Polo Double Black, but never seemed to get the endless re-imaging of the Red or Blue scents.

As usual, I will explore what it smells like, how it performs, when it should be worn, and whether or not I think it’s worth a purchase. Note: I am updating and adding to this review,  years after the original, and spending more time with this fragrance. 

What Does Polo Black Smell Like?

Notes include:  mango, sandalwood, tonka bean, tangerine, sage, lemon, patchouli

Click here to try: Polo Black by Ralph Lauren for Men – 4.2 Ounce EDT Spray

My Polo Black Review

The opening of Polo Black features a striking mango note, that is accompanied by an underlying woodsy spice, provided by the patchouli and sage notes. This is a fruity type of aroma, but it isn’t overly sweet, like some other tropical noted scents out there.

It takes a different tact from Polo Double Black, which I previously reviewed, and sticks to being a much brighter fragrance than the darker coffee and spice of its flanker scent. I really find it interesting, how the sage plays off of the mango, which is itself a pretty unique choice for a fruit note in a men’s cologne.

Aside from the mango, (mostly) tangerine is present in the beginning, and gives this one a further tropical sort of appeal. The citrus is juicy and with the mango, allows Polo Black to have a watery aroma, which is energetic and refreshing.

The herbal and earthy spice give it some added depth in the beginning, but never overpower the fruit notes or even reach equality with their strength.

During the dry down period, the woodsy notes begin to take more prominence. The smooth and familiar sandalwood note comes through and I can detect the tonka bean as well, which is one of my favorite notes.

Also, the lemon and tangerine are still there somewhat, which gives the top layer an added citrusy zest to it. The citrus is nice, a welcome addition really,  but isn’t the main attraction.

To me, the opening act of Polo Black is the most dynamic aspect of this fragrance. You get an interesting development and contrast, between fruits, spices and wood. After that, the cologne becomes much more of a linear affair.

It’s mango, citrus as a background, sandalwood, and tonka bean. This Ralph Lauren fragrance, becomes less juicy, and has more of its dry woody element come through.

Sillage, Longevity, Versatility

Polo Black is a moderate type of fragrance with good projection, but it isn’t really great, in that regard. The longevity is also moderate, it is usually better than Double Black, which only lasts 4-5 hours on my skin.

However, Black isn’t a beast in terms of its use, for me at least. Six or seven hours, maybe. Don’t expect a complete monster with its sillage or staying power. Nonetheless, it is a completely serviceable cologne, and not weak at all.

The neat thing about this fragrance is that it kind of is a year round scent. It works in the summertime pretty well but can also be worn (and is better), in the fall and winter months.

I’d say this scent is like a ‘dressy’ casual, in that, it works well for work and school but it can be worn out if need be. It does have some pretty nice versatility.

Is it an attractive fragrance? Yes, women seem to really enjoy this one. It will get complements, fairly often, and can be a nice go-to for younger guys to wear on a date and the like. Polo Black is the type of scent that has pretty universal appeal and isn’t going to be polarizing to have on.

Overall Impression of Polo Black

Overall, I do think that this is a really good effort from Polo. I wish the projection and longevity were better (maybe, an intense version that Double Black should have been) but for what it is, this is a nice cologne. Again, it isn’t poor quality, just would enjoy more of a powerhouse.

It smells great, and does have a unique enough feel, for guys who want to stand out a bit from the crowd. On the flipside, this one is completely safe, and very versatile in its applications.

The mango note has the advantage of being delicious and attractive, but being underused in most men’s fragrance. Hence, it can put on the air of being unique, while the rest of the composition, is fairly commonplace.

Over the years, I’ve come to appreciate Polo Black, more and more. It’s kind of underrated, at this point. It’s a do-it-all cologne, that people enjoy, and provides a solid value. I recommend giving it a try.

I still think that it’s one of the best fragrances that the brand ever came out with, maybe the best, for all of the bases that it covers.

Best Men's Colognes

Best Men’s Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with different fragrances, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, I have written hundreds of reviews and other pages about perfumes and colognes.