As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on an Amazon affiliate link on my pages, I receive a commission based on that qualified purchase. It doesn't cost you any more money and it helps keep the site running.
For this head to head cologne comparison, I am going to take a closer look at two Carolina Herrera fragrances from the 212 lineup: 212 VIP vs. 212 VIP Black. Which of these nightlife scents, smells the best? VIP Black was released in 2017, as a follow up flanker to the original, but does it surpass VIP? Which has better performance? Which should you buy?
Tale of the Tape: 212 Black vs. VIP
212 VIP
Notes include: caviar lime, frozen mint, black pepper, vodka, ginger, amber, apple, King wood, tonka bean
Click here to try: 212 Vip by Carolina Herrera Eau De Toilette Spray for Men, 3.4 Ounce
Read my review: 212 VIP
212 VIP Black
Notes include: absinthe, leather, lavender, musk, vanilla, amber, anise
Click here to try: Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black Men Eau de Parfum 3.4oz / 100ml – Launched in 2017
Read my review: 212 VIP Black
Opening
The opening of 212 VIP is a smooth boozy aroma with a spicy blast. You get the alcoholic note of vodka, creamy tonka bean, amber, and the pepper to give it a kick. It’s sweet and warm with mixed drink undertones of lime and mint.
VIP Black, on the other hand, also has a boozy start but this time it is absinthe. Like it’s predecessor, Black has a warm amber note and spice, but it’s a weaker anise in lieu of pepper. Add to this, lavender and a quite faint leather note.
Which is better? The original 212 VIP has a much more interesting and better smelling opening, especially after a few minutes, when the vodka note settles. VIP Black is nice and I like the absinthe, but it just isn’t as attractive.
Edge: 212 VIP
Projection
212 VIP has been known as a strong scent, with beast sillage. It is the type you can spray and people will definitely notice it. VIP is absolutely a nightlife fragrance, as such, it is going to be loud and boisterous.
Does VIP Black have a similar profile? Unfortunately, no. It is a light to moderate scent and doesn’t seem to be able to project itself very well at all.
Edge: 212 VIP
Longevity
Again, I get 10+ hours of wear from my bottle of the original. It’s performance is really top notch. With Black, I could only muster 5-6 hours of wear, and most of that it had fairly weak sillage.
Edge: 212 VIP
Versatility
All right, so, both of these are pretty limited colognes and are designed specifically for nightlife wear. They both are good in cold weather, but not when it gets warm. Neither is very casual or an office safe type of scent. They pretty much fit the same bill, as to be expected with flanker fragrances.
Edge: Push
Overall Scent
I was really excited to try 212 VIP Black because I enjoy the original, as a bold go to scent on some evenings. If it could have been another monster performer, with a different take on the booze soaked cologne genre, I would have been quite happy.
The problem is, it just doesn’t perform up to par, and what smell there is isn’t as good as the original. VIP Black has that nice boozy opening and then settles into something that is sweet with a bit of musk.
Vanilla, amber, and musk are pretty much the dry down and the absinthe and spice is hardly noticeable.
212 VIP, isn’t a fragrance for everyone, many people won’t enjoy a bomb of a fragrance with a vodka note at the center of it. Understandable, but I still like throwing it on, because of it’s sweet boozy demeanor and very nice dry down. It’s a club banger, at an affordable price. It wins this head to head rather easily.
Winner: 212 VIP
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
User Review
( votes)
Best Men’s Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with different fragrances, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, I have written hundreds of reviews and other pages about perfumes and colognes.