Acqua di Gio Profondo vs Profondo Lights

Acqua di Gio continues to spawn off flankers, 25 years after the original was released. The latest is the Profondo side of things, with the awesome original, and 2021’s Profondo Lights. Being a big fan of AdG Profondo, I was excited to be able to try out Lights and see if I had another one to enjoy. Which of these fragrances is better? Which lasts longer? Which should you buy?

Tale of the Tape: AdG Profondo vs. Profondo Lights

Acqua di Gio Profondo

Notes include: mandarin, bergamot, lavender, marine notes, rosemary, cypress, lentisk, patchouli, musk

Click here to try: GIORGIO ARMANI Acqua Di Gio Profondo for Men Eau De Parfum Spray 4.2 Ounces, blue

Read my Review: AdG Profondo

Profondo Lights

Notes include: cardamom, mandarin, patchouli, cedar, marine accord, vetiver, lavender, cypress, rosemary

Opening

Acqua di Gio Profondo starts off with its citrus notes in the lead, bergamot and mandarin orange. The bergamot is the more dominant of the two ingredients. It’s a good deal amount like the original AdG. However, it doesn’t have the same floral focus, is more marine, and has a resinous quality.

It’s not too salty of a marine accord, rather it gives an aquatic impression, versus being a oceanic  scent.

Profondo Lights goes in a different direction initially. I’ve said that Profondo is a blue fragrance with green-ish qualities, well, Lights reverses that.

It opens up with a bright use of the mandarin, a heavy bit of cardamom, and cypress coming through as the main bout of woody freshness. All of this is sitting on top of the marine accord.

Which is better? I prefer the opening of Profondo versus Profondo Lights. The initial few minutes of Lights, really doesn’t work well on me. It actually reminds me of having a less harsh apple cider vinegar aroma.

That does change and it gets better, but that alone doesn’t let it get to the same level of enjoyment as Profondo.

Edge: Profondo

Projection

Profondo starts out in the stronger sillage camp, but settles fairly quickly into the moderate. It’s got decent projection but isn’t ever super powerful.

Profondo Lights starts out as a moderate, never has the same strength, and sits much closer to the skin for a majority of the wear. Not completely weak, but fairly average overall.

Edge: Profondo

Longevity

AdG Profondo gives me a consistent 7-8 hours of wear. Admittedly, it’s not amazingly long lasting, but that’s a workday’s worth of wear. It’s solid.

Profondo Lights is again, a step behind. This stuff is gone from my skin in 5-6 hours. Not a complete waste, but it’s outdone by its competitor and Profumo.

Edge: Profondo

Versatility

I don’t really feel that there is much of a difference between these two, in terms of when they can be worn. Seasonally, I’d stick to spring and summer for both. Beyond that, they’re both fine in casual to semi-formal situations.

This one is an even split for me, no real advantage to either fragrance.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

This is an easy win for the original Profondo. Lights tries to go in a new direction, does some things well, but ultimately doesn’t really provide too much that is interesting to me.

Profondo Lights opening act is pretty bad. I don’t know if it’s just something with how it works on me, but I actively dislike the start. The blend of the mandarin, cardamom, and cypress just feels off to me.

Although, I like the latter stages, when it settles down…it’s never a love. It becomes more like Profondo, but Lights has a greener and more marine depth to it. One problem that I have with it, is that is has an underlying bitterness to the scent, that I don’t enjoy.

Overall, Profondo Lights isn’t a bad cologne. It ends up being okay, but that’s about it. The performance doesn’t do it any favors either.

Meanwhile, I am a big fan of Acqua di Gio Profondo. Along with Profumo, it is a favorite of mine from the series. It’s smooth, blue, with a great citrus opening and it’s a fragrance that I have loved wearing during the summer.

This isn’t a contest for me, I’d rather wear Profondo over Lights every time. The cardamom doesn’t add much for me and actually throws off the composition, in my opinion, and I’m someone who likes a good cardamom note. Here, it’s all just mehhh.

Winner: Profondo

Best Men's Colognes

Best Men’s Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with different fragrances, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, I have written hundreds of reviews and other pages about perfumes and colognes.