Best Men's Colognes

Best Men's Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with the different fragrances that I've owned, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, that new hobby grew into a consistent passion, helping millions of readers along the way. I have personally written reviews for well over 800 perfumes and colognes for both men and women. This is along with writing hundreds of other in-depth fragrance guides. You can also follow me on: YouTube, Instagram, and Tiktok!

Givenchy Gentleman Reserve Privee vs. Dior Homme Intense

by

Two iris fragrances for men, are among the two most popular cologne options for guys: Dior Homme Intense and Gentleman Reserve Privee by Givenchy. Add to that, they each have a dark warmth about them, and plenty of shared notes. The question is, which smells better? Which one lasts longer? Which is the better buy?

Tale of the Tape: Dior Intense vs. Gentleman Reserve Privee

Dior Homme Intense

Notes include: pear, iris, vetiver, ambrette, lavender, cedar

Click here to try: Christian Dior Dior Men Intense Eau de Parfum Spray, 3.4 Ounce

Read my review: Dior Homme Intense

Gentleman Reserve Privee

Notes include: bergamot, iris, benzoin, whiskey absolute, chestnut, cedar, vetiver and patchouli

Click here to try: Reserve Privee at Macy’s

Read my review: Reserve Privee

Opening

Homme Intense starts with a mix of lavender, cedar, and vetiver. It’s a smooth woody scent that pairs with the ambrette to create a warmer woods feeling. The iris emerges on my skin, after a minute or so delivering the signature floral note of each scent.

The ambrette creates a cacao-like aroma, that was found in the original Dior Homme. Sweet, warm, and just fantastic.

The opening of Gentleman Reserve Privee shares a lot with the two Dior fragrances, along with, Uomo by Valentino.

Bergamot and chestnut come through early to give it a fresh and nutty aroma. It actually starts to settle into more of a cacao smell, but it is pure chestnut at the beginning. The iris of course, is there too.

It really does favor smelling like Dior Homme Intense, at this stage. But, the main highlight is the whiskey note. Warm, dark, and very appealing.

Which is better? For me, the opening hour is a pretty close call. They are very similar and are both excellent openers. I do think that I still prefer Dior Intense a bit more than this newer Givenchy release.

Dior Intense is one of my favorite openers of all-time, I don’t think Reserve does anything to completely surpass it.

Edge: Dior Intense

Projection

Dior Intense has a nice and strong first few hours, that will for sure leave a scent trail behind. Not a powerhouse, but it’s always been well above average on me. Even if I couldn’t smell it at a particular moment, others have commented on it.

Reserve Privee doesn’t reach that same peak in the beginning. Plus, it falls off into something that is on the lighter side of moderate. Not completely weak, just not up to the Dior level.

Edge: Intense

Longevity

With this one, Dior Intense usually gives me in the 9-11 hour range of wear. I think I get a bit better performance out of this one, than most people for whatever reason.

The Givenchy lasted 8-9 hours on skin. So, it’s upper end can match what Dior does sometimes, but it doesn’t have that extra gear.

Again, for some people, this might actually be equal. For me, it’s Dior.

Edge: Intense

Versatility

These two inhabit the same sphere and share so many overlaps, there’s no real distinction here.

Both are autumn and wintertime wears. Both tend towards being nightlife wears, with mass appeal and sexiness. But, also there’s not problem wearing it in the daytime usually. Classy, well put together, etc.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

Overall, which of these fragrances do I enjoy more? It’s the Dior.

Reserve Privee was a scent that I was pretty excited to try out, but ultimately a bit underwhelmed by. Now, I do think that opening is awesome and trying it again and again, it still captures my attention.

But, after that, this one just doesn’t hold up in the same way. Nor does it ever hit the same peak as Dior Intense. The whiskey note doesn’t stick around long enough, the nuttiness of chestnut becomes more of a dry chocolate (which is nice), but even that isn’t an extended stay.

Mostly, it’s the iris, amber, and wood. Not a bad smell, but just kind of boring and doesn’t bring the same punch as the Dior. The Givenchy isn’t a bad cologne, it’s just never as good, and tries to tread over much of the same ground.

Winner: Dior Intense

4 Fragrances that Smell Similar to Afternoon Swim

by

Louis Vuitton’s Afternoon Swim is one of their best fragrances and a simple yet potent fragrance that is amazing in the summer months. It’s also one with a hefty price tag. But, if you enjoy the smell, here is my running list of perfumes that can deliver a closely related experience

What Perfumes Smell Similar to Afternoon Swim?

Swimming Scent

Gone Swimming– If you’re looking for a near perfect match, Gone Swimming by the Dua Brand is the one that you will probably want to go with.

Personally, I went with their inspired blend of the Louis Vuitton and Creed’s Virgin Island Water, called Gone Swimming in Caribbean Waters.  The added coconut and rum notes are really great and create a beachy fragrance.

However, the original Gone Swimming formula has the citrus notes that make the LV perfume great, done right. The price is also currently $60 for the full bottle, with a smaller size now available too. Performance is actually better than the Vuitton original, also.

Similar Citrus, Designer Style

Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue Forever for Men by Dolce & Gabbana Eau De Parfum,3.3 Fl Oz– Whereas Afternoon Swim goes with the orange and bergamot combination, Light Blue Forever is much more focused on the grapefruit note. Very realistic grapefruit, with a side of bergamot.

Instead of the amber, this one goes more greenish/ozonic with how it comes across. Violet leaf, a dry vetiver, and fresh musk round things out and have a greater influence later on in the wear.

Forever is a fresher cologne than Afternoon, but doesn’t have the same level of dynamic mix from the citrus notes. Really wonderful grapefruit, though. Light Blue Forever Review

A Tygar in Your Tank

Tygar by Bvlgari– By no means is this a cheapie. Tygar is right up there in price, if not more expensive than a bottle of the Louis Vuitton. It just provides you another great luxury summer citrus, with a simple formula.

It sort of splits the difference between Afternoon Swim and L’Immensite by LV. L’Immensite is spicier and might have a tad more amber. This one goes with a heavy use of grapefruit (feels like some orange is there too), as the citrus. With amber and wood to round things out.

A fresher citrus, but has enough in common with Swim, that you’d probably enjoy wearing this one too. Also, Dua Brand has a blend of their version of Tygar and Afternoon Swim available.

Another Cheaper Option

Turathi Blue by Afnan– Ok, this one is in the same vein as Tygar and Afternoon Swim, with some similarities to Bleu de Chanel too. Again, if you want a closer alternative, go with the Dua.

Turathi gives you it’s own blend of citrus, not as grapefruit dominant as Tygar, but  for sure leans that way. There’s some other stuff here, maybe bergamot? The opening is fairly sharp, but this one settles nicely.

It’s got some fresh musk, the amber, and a general woodiness. I don’t think the amber is quite as heavy, as the other scents. For the $40 or thereabouts, this is a nice and easy to wear citrus, that actually lasts a long time.

Idôle Nectar by Lancôme

by

Nectar is the latest flanker of the Idôle line, released by Lancôme in 2022. I have tried out the others in the series and was curious as to what this one would be like and where it would take the line. How does Nectar smell? Does it last long? Is it worth a try?

What does Idole Nectar Smell Like?

Notes include: rose, popcorn, caramel, vanilla

Click here to try: Idole Nectar

idole nectar review

My Full Review

Here’s how Lancôme describes it: Idôle L’Eau de Parfum Nectar is an olfactory treat, a reinvention of the sweet and floral fragrance. A unique, avant-garde scent which marries a faceted rose bouquet with a sweet blast of popcorn deliciousness, Idôle Nectar cannot be ignored, and rather is meant to stand out.

Nectar starts off with a sweet blast, that’s almost fruity with the way it comes across, and somewhat green. Not sure what it is, it kind of reminds me of the osmanthus note in Flowerbomb, but nothing like that is listed by Lancôme.

Bergamot and pear have been used in the other perfumes in this line, perhaps they have been snuck in here too, and are interacting with the roses.

Underneath that, is the variety of rose types, and a caramel popcorn accord. Yes, this Nectar is the gourmand version of the Idole series. It is also the one which goes full on with the rose, instead of a rose and jasmine blend like EDP and Aura.

After a few minutes, the rose really starts to take over. The ‘fruity’ sweetness has faded and it’s a warmer deliciousness of caramel popcorn and vanilla. I was expecting this to be a buttery sort of aroma, with those three notes, but it’s really not. Also, not salty, like Idole Aura is.

The dry down is a fresh rose with mostly the vanilla. It’s more of a pinkish rose blend, Centifolia is the official listing from Lancôme. Along with rose water (freshness) and rose absolute. It is a very easy to wear perfume, even if you’re not a huge rose fan (I’m not, myself).

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Sillage wise, I think that this has a slightly stronger reach than Idôle Aura, but the longevity is a step behind. Not much of a difference, but that initial hour or two, seems a tad better than Aura a leaving a scent trail.

Then, it is back to the 3-5 foot range, just like its predecessor.

The longevity is in the 6.5-7.5 range versus the 8 I can get with Aura. I timed it twice on my skin and 7.5 hours was the max that I got with Nectar. Not bad.

Seasonally, I came into this expecting something heavier and more winter based. But, that’s not actually the case. It’s fresh and not overly cloying. Actually, it be fine in most temperatures except the extreme heat of summer.

This is mostly a daytime type of wear. Not too formal or too casual or just exclusively for teenagers. It’s probably good up to semi-formal occasions.

I do think that it could venture into the nightlife, if need be. Nectar does have a certain sexiness to it, not really sultry, but certainly quite attractive.

Overall Impressions of Idôle Nectar

Overall, do I like this scent? Yes, as of now it is my second favorite from the series. L’Intense is the best overall, in my mind. But, this is slightly better than Aura and pretty easily exceeds the original.

I enjoy that they went in a gourmand direction with Nectar. The caramel popcorn and vanilla are great here. Not too heavy or cloying, still very wearable in some warmer temperatures. The initial sweetness and later use of the rose, make for a very pretty perfume.

The performance is above average. It never reaches the realm of spectacular, just a well performing and one that can go close to a full workday with normal sprays.

Idôle Nectar is one from the series to try out. It doesn’t stay crazy sweet or overly sugared and the rose notes are actually pretty tame and wearable. Even if, you’re generally not a rose lover. With this perfume, you don’t need to be.

Rive Gauche by Yves Saint Laurent

by

Rive Gauche is an absolutely classic fragrance from Yves Saint Laurent which dates back to 1971. As a consequence, this became a daily wear staple for a few generations of women. I got a hold of a decant to revisit this one, after probably close to 10 years of not coming across this perfume. How does it smell? How long does it last? Is it still worth a try?

What does Rive Gauche Smell Like?

Notes include: peach, lemon, honeysuckle, aldehydes, rose, oakmoss, vetiver, iris, musk, and more

My Full Review

Note: I am reviewing a decant from one of the later bottles of this perfume (not sure what year), after not experiencing it for a handful of years. Probably one that is considered to be ‘reformulated’ from the original 70s offering. 

Rive Gauche opens up with a fresh icy burst of aldehydes, light crisp fruit notes, and a further dewy/greenish sort of aroma. Personally, I tend to pick up a peach note, as the main aspect of the fruit accord. Though, that’s not overwhelming.

It is an interesting mix of dry freshness, the dew aroma, and the floral notes. The opening has an underlying dryness to it thanks to the oak moss and vetiver notes. The aldehydes here, always bring to mind Chanel for me, but Rive Gauche has a very dynamic and distinct personality all its own.

The floral notes do emerge, once we get past the start. I mean, rose comes across somewhat early, but this really becomes about the white floral notes. Gardenia and lily of the valley are going to be main attractions for this portion.

Iris, will help add a powdery smell for a duration, but that seems to disappear on my skin. I get much more powder, if I spray this one on clothing.

As it dries down, Rive Gauche still has that cold feeling, but the muskiness starts to ramp up when I wear it. The floral notes are less distinct from one another. I will say, once the iris has had its little run, its: rose, lily of the valley, and jasmine.

The final dry down is going to be woodier and muskier. Sandalwood, vetiver, and musk are the main trio. The floral note and aldehydes are all that remain from earlier, but sit underneath those notes, and are more of a generic impression than being easy to separate out.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

The sillage is actually fairly strong, on the whole. This will leave a trail behind you and can reach pretty far across the room, at least early on.

It does moderate fairly quickly, with a limited amount of sprays. But, Rive Gauche does give you the option of going heavy and getting a much better performance.

The decant that I had, had really a really solid wear time. I could get it to last on skin for between 8-8.5 hours, during testing. Nothing insanely good, but still nothing to be disappointed in.

Seasonally, this could be worn almost anytime. I’d pick something else for the extremes of winter and summer, but outside of that, no worries. It’s ideal in springtime, though.

It’s very versatile as a daily wear. Not really a sexy nightlife perfume, but one with an ability to go more formal, if need be. While still finding a way to be fairly casual, also.

Overall Impressions of Rive Gauche

Do I like Rive Gauche? Yes, this is an example of an aldehyde soaked white floral fragrance that I enjoy. It’s not one of my favorite types of perfume, but this YSL is one, that I’ve always appreciated.

I was reminded of Rive Gauche again by two perfumes, one a Cartier (that I liked, can’t remember which), and one was Guilty Love Edition by Gucci (not a like). Both had a similar style, while not duplicating the Saint Laurent’s exact aroma.

I like the initial cold freshness with the hints of peach and even the greenish qualities. The floral notes are there doing their thing, with an increasing influence as we move along. There’s plenty of depth here and a classic style.

This may not be one for everybody, but it has been appreciated for over 50 years, for a reason. Rive Gauche is likeable and one that you can return to again and again.

Idôle Aura by Lancôme

by

Aura is a flanker fragrance release from Lancôme’s Idole line, that came out in 2021. This was one of the perfume samples that I picked up a while back in order to test it out. I was interested to see how this one is distinct from the original EDP. What does Aura smell like? Does it last long? Is it worth a try?

What does Idole Aura Smell Like?

Notes include: bergamot, vanilla, rose, jasmine, salt, musk

Click here to try: From Lancome

idole aura review

My Full Review

Here’s how Lancôme describes it: As unique and unstoppable as the energy that radiates from within every Idôle – share the light of success with Idôle Aura as its ambience transfers from one Idôle to another. From Idôle Aura to you and the Idôle’s who surround you.

The opening spray of Aura shares the bergamot and jasmine notes, found in Idole EDP. It lacks the pear and pink pepper notes of that one, but seems to include a muskier top in their stead.

It is interesting that Aura has a beachy vibe to it, thanks to the inclusion of a salted vanilla note. Sort of reminds me of saltwater taffey from when I was a kid. This does have a nice sweetness to it, but isn’t overwhelming. In fact, the vanilla floral mix has more of a powdery aroma for a good part of the wear.

Like the original, as we move along, the rose note will become more prominent in the mix. Beyond that, the rose and jasmine notes start to achieve a balanced relationship.

Idole Aura is warm, slightly sweet, salty with a nice floral/musk mix that smells like Idole EDP. It’s like they stripped a few things off of that and added more vanilla and that salty flair.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

The sillage here is pretty strong, especially for the first few hours. Not a complete monster, but it leaves a trail and has a solidly far radius from off of the skin. For much of the rest of the wear, it’ll be a 3-5 foot range from skin.

The longevity is good, above average, but not amazing. I get 7.5-8 hours with it. Most of the last hour or so it a floral and faint vanilla smell, but Aura is still there.

Like the original Idole EDP, this one is best served by being used in the spring and summer months. I like this more in the summer, thanks to that beachy vibe. It’s not as good here in the December cold, but not completely out of place. There are just better options.

Aura is more of a casual daytime wear. It can probably be used as a daily wear during the warmer months to the office or something, since it’s not overwhelming or anything inappropriate.

Aura is also more of a pleasant crowd pleaser versus being a sexy nightlife scent. Also, suitable for a wide age range. Teens could wear this, along with more mature women. Vey nice balance and doesn’t feel cheap.

Overall Impressions of Idole Aura

Overall, do I like Idole Aura? I do. To me, it’s a bit better than the eau de parfum. But, from this series, I like Nectar and L’Intense more than this one.

I like the opening act with the jasmine and bergamot. That’s a pretty common combination, but it works well. Add to that, the vanilla and salty beachy aroma, and Aura does deliver a sun-kissed scent that’s enjoyable to wear.

The performance here is above average across the board. Aura was never totally weak, until the denouement, and it gave around a full work day’s worth of wear. Yes, there are better performers, but this one is just fine.

The final dry down is closer to the original with the jasmine, rose, and muskiness. However, it retains a lot of what makes it distinct. Namely, the fresh marine qualities and warmer solar aspects.

Idole Aura is a perfume that is well worth checking out. Not overly complicated, but a scent that a lot of people should like.