Best Men's Colognes

Best Men's Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with the different fragrances that I've owned, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, that new hobby grew into a consistent passion, helping millions of readers along the way. I have personally written reviews for well over 800 perfumes and colognes for both men and women. This is along with writing hundreds of other in-depth fragrance guides. You can also follow me on: YouTube, Instagram, and Tiktok!

Cool Water vs. Acqua di Gio Cologne Comparison

by

So, in this head to head cologne match up, we are going to take a closer look at two of the best selling men’s fragrances of all time: Acqua di Gio vs. Cool Water. It’s an early vs. late 1990s competition, but which of these famous scent smells the best? Which gives the better performance? Has greater versatility? Which is the better buy today?

Tale of the Tape: AdG vs. Cool Water

Acqua di Gio

Notes include: bergamot, tangerine, neroli, jasmine, rosemary, patchouli, rock rose, hyacinth, persimmon, marine notes

Click here to try: Acqua Di Gio By Giorgio Armani For Men. Eau De Toilette Spray 3.4 Ounces

Read my review: Acqua di Gio 

Cool Water

Notes include: lavender, mint, tobacco, amber, musk, jasmine, sandalwood, neroli, coriander, rosemary, and more

Click here to try: Davidoff Cool Water Edt Spray for Men, 6.7 oz

Read my Review: Cool Water

Opening

Davidoff’s Cool Water opens up with a refreshing aquatic aroma laced with mint and tobacco. The smell is pretty sharp and green, as the tobacco note doesn’t have that cured scent that you’d find in a cigarette or cigar.

Beyond that, Cool Water has a soapy element that comes in, when its floral notes begin to take center stage. It always stays aquatic but it does have various facets of its personality.

Meanwhile, Acqua di Gio, hits right off the bat with tangerine and bergamot. It’s a great and delicious citrus start, that also has more of a sea breeze aquatic aroma versus, the actual watery scent of the Davidoff. Jasmine also joins in for added depth.

I recently tested out Acqua again while at a store and that opening still hits. Really an amazing balance in that fragrance.

Which is better? I prefer AdG over the Cool Water. I like the mint and tobacco opening of Cool Water, less so, when the soapy aspect kicks in. With AdG, I really love that citrus blast and great summer feel.

Edge: AdG

Projection

The projection on both of these scents is pretty moderate. Neither has crazy strong sillage. I think AdG is slightly better nowadays, so it gets the edge. They used to be pretty much on par with one another, but Cool Water isn’t the same cologne that it once was, in terms of performance.

Edge: AdG

Longevity

If you get an older bottle of Cool Water, it’ll last over 8 hours. Reformulations happen over time and the latest batch I tried was 6-7 hours. Acqua di Gio also gets 6-7 of wear on my skin, before it fades. Both are decent, but not extreme performers.

Cool Water used to have an edge. Actually, both used to be better than their current formulations. Nowadays, there’s no real winner. It might entirely depend on the batch that you get.

Edge: Push

Versatility

Both of these colognes really shine in the warmer weather, but are so versatile as to be wearable year round. They are office safe and can go completely casual.

AdG is probably sexier and has more ability to be a nighttime wear…but it’s not really a club scent. Not much advantage here. I might be tempted to lean more towards AdG, since I think it’ll have more appeal among younger guys.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

I’ve tried both of these fragrances many times over the years and have a clear idea about which I prefer to wear. Cool Water is a nice scent, it has changed over the years, and smells like it has been altered somewhat from what I remember.

It’s not completely different, but noticeable if you’ve come across that vintage bottle. I like how it develops, while maintaining that aquatic scent. From the opening to the soapy middle to the dry woods, that kicks in after an hour or so. For the price, it’s a solid everyday choice.

Acqua di Gio is just better. It’s not my favorite cologne in the world, but I do enjoy wearing it from time to time. It is more enjoyable to me, than is Cool Water. It is a classic blend of citrus, wood, and that aquatic sea breeze.

Plus, floral undertones to give it more character. The jasmine note really stuck out to me, the last time around. It was just so good with that opening bergamot and tangerine, with the marine influence.

Both have been best sellers for a reason, but the Armani takes the cake.

Winner: Acqua di Gio

6 Fragrances Similar to Idole by Lancome

by

Idole has been a massive success for Lancôme since its release. Not only the original, but the subsequent flanker perfume releases, adding their own unique touches to the formula. But, what if you’re in the market for something that’s a cheaper and similar option to Idole? Or, what if you want something with a close style, but brings something else to the table?

On this page, I am going to be keeping track of the potential options for those who want an alternative to Lancôme Idole.

What Perfumes Smell Like or are Similar to Lancôme Idole?

Idôle review

Inspired By

Floral Musk by Dossier–  The first option on the list, is going to be Dossier’s inspired take on the Idole formula. It’s going to be the best quality choice for those who want a cheaper and very closely related scent to the original Idole.

The notes? Still going to give you the pear, lychee, and bergamot opening act. Which will give way to the jasmine and rose combination in the middle.

Now, this is going to be as close as you can currently get for something near matches the Lancôme fragrance. As always, the weightings and ingredients used might not be 100% exact, but most people wouldn’t be able to notice anyway.

Nectar Alternative

Ideal Nectar by Dua– Here is the Dua Brand’s take on the aroma of Idole Nectar, which is one of the flankers of the series.

Actually, Nectar is my second favorite Idole scent, after L’Intense. One of the highlights is the caramel popcorn note paired with vanilla. Within the blend, it’s actually not a super heavy accord, and the perfume is well balanced by the fresh/sweetness of the early stages.

Rose is a main draw too. To me, it was a pink rose, and it goes with the vanilla in the dry down stage.

So, if you want a version of that flanker perfume, you can try out the Dua Ideal Nectar option listed above.

idole nectar review

Dirt Cheap Mist

You’re the One by Bath and Body Works– There is also a perfume version of this one, that you might have to track down, as I didn’t see it on my cursory look for this post.

Anyway, as a cheap alternative, this is actually a great B&BW fragrance. Sweet strawberry, rose, and a somewhat smoky woody base. Less candy-like with the strawberry, more of a jam pairing with the rose note.

Greatly simplified versus Idole, but it really does give you a similar effect. Can be an awesome pick up, if you just want something casual to preserve your bottle of Idole, also.

Aura Alike

Aura of Roses by Dua– Here’s another one from Dua. This time, it’s their inspired take on Idole Aura.

Aura, was a fairly simple flanker, that had a salty and somewhat beachy vibe for a good portion of the wear. Less sweet, more floral and musky. The opening was heavier on the jasmine, while the latter stages was rose and vanilla.

Stripped down, but with more vanilla and that salt note. Instead of salted caramel popcorn. So, if that’s you’re bag and you want a cheaper perfume, this Dua should do the trick.

idole aura review

Now Petals

Viva La Juicy Petals Please- Petals Please is a perfume that has a lot in common with Idole Now. It takes the Viva La Juicy formula into a much more floral focused direction, that is very bouquet-like with how it comes across.

Petals Please opens up fruitier with its cloudberry note, which while being unique, has a light citrusy type of aroma. It’s interesting, not exactly citrus but kind of hits the same way. With that, you still get vanilla and some salty caramel popping up early.

The rose note is a ‘rose water’, which with the freesia gives Petals Please a very slight aquatic feel at times. Magnolia, gardenia, jasmine, and water lily also make appearances.

More of a fresh and watery feel to this, further into the dry down. Though, it’s still not massive. Rose, vanilla, caramel, jasmine, and the like give this one a lot in common with the Lancome line.

Relentless Similarities

Tory Burch Love Relentlessly 3.4 Oz Eau De Parfum Spray For Women– This is another one that is similar to Idole Nectar. However, it’s not the same.

A patchouli-laden fruit mix that is sweet, but not overly sugary. It has a warm pink pepper spice that isn’t too intense and plays nicely off of the patchouli note.

The main fruit note smells something like mango, though, I’m not entirely sure that this is in fact the ingredient. I think it might just be the way that raspberry and the other fruits blend together.

The fruitiness, is fairly dominant up top. Then, you get the pink pepper spice, while the floral notes develop.

Here, it is going to be some iris and rose, which gives this scent a somewhat powdery aroma. Love Relentlessly has good performance and while sweet doesn’t have a huge sillage.

Patchouli is a major factor here, so that might put some folks off to this perfume. That’s going to be the main difference between this and Nectar.

5 Fragrances Similar to Imagination by Louis Vuitton

by

Imagination has become one of the most popular releases from Louis Vuitton, over the past few years. It’s also my own personal favorite thus far from the designer. Though, sometimes, you may not want to pay the LV prices for a bottle and want to find something cheaper.

Or, you like the style, but maybe one note bothers you. So, you want something similar, but that takes this citrus type of fragrance in a different direction. In either case, I am going to use this page to keep track of colognes that I find which can fit the bill and be an alternative to Imagination.

What fragrances smell like or are similar to Imagination by Louis Vuitton?

The Inspired Imagination

#Imagine by Dua– #Imagine is the Dua Brand’s inspired take on the Imagination formula. This is one that I bought to test and it ended up being a great and near identical match of our target fragrance.

The notes are the same and the weightings of each are almost perfect. The black tea, the citrus, the amber, etc. All here and all are wonderful.

#Imagine is the one that I would recommend going with first, if you want a cheaper alternative to Imagination, that tries to do the same things.

imagination dupe

Mirror Mirroring

Mind’s Mirror by Oakcha– Here’s another option for an inspired cheaper take on the Imagination fragrance idea.

Now, I haven’t tried this one out from Oakcha. But, the brand has some good stuff and they usually do a good job at matching what they’re going for.

I’d go with #Imagine above, since it’s a known quantity for me. But, here’s a different one for you, if you want to go with another brand for whatever reason.

Cologne Similarities

Dior Homme Cologne– Dior Homme Cologne is another of the fresh citrus warm weather fragrances. Not going to be the same as Imagination, but it’ll give you a similar style.

Here, you’re going to share the bergamot note with the Louis Vuitton scent. But, the floral note here is a grapefruit blossom, instead of neroli. So, instead of an orangey aroma its grapefruit.

Greatly simplified and doesn’t have the same level of depth as Imagination. Basically: citrus, citrus blossom, and musk. However, it all comes together for a great summertime wear.

I have a bottle of this, also. It’s a part of my rotation with #Imagine in the warmer months of the year. Maybe give this one a go, if you want a more streamlined option of this type of cologne. Dior Homme Cologne Review

Ideal Alternative

L’Homme Ideal Platine Prive by Guerlain– Another French designer, that brings out a reworking of one of its older offerings. Platine Prive is very much like the old Ideal Cologne, that was discontinued years ago.

However, to me, that was the best of the series. And I’m very happy that Guerlain decided to give us this enhanced version.

This one gives you a citrus top that is very much like Imagination’s starting notes. However, here you’re going to get almond as the centerpiece instead of the black tea note.

Clean, some level of greenish aromas, smooth, and nutty. No, it’s not going to smell exactly like Imagination, and that’s the point. It provides its own awesome wear experience, while occupying the same sort of space as our target.

Finding a bottle, will probably require you to order it online. As this one, isn’t available in all countries.

Alluring Chanel

Allure Homme Sport Cologne by Chanel– This Chanel actually has a tremendous overlap with Dior Homme Cologne. Though, I like the Dior slightly more than it. In general, I’d go with that one, as it’s more readily available and usually cheaper.

This is probably the least well known offering in the Allure Homme series. It really gets overlooked.

Sport Cologne, however, does utilize a resinous elemi note that can give you a bit of a different feel and replicates this sort of summer scent in an attractive package.

Again, this isn’t an option that is going to be a close match to Imagination. It’s one that can give you a great alternative option for those who want something in the same ballpark. Allure Homme Sport Cologne Review

6 Fragrances Similar to Ralph Lauren Romance

by

Romance is a consistent best-selling perfume for Ralph Lauren. It is a fairly simple fragrance, but one which has garnered many fans, and spawned some imitators. In this post, I want to explore some fragrances that are comparable, smell similar, or are just cheaper alternatives to the RL scent. These smell alikes, all have different takes on a similar aroma, but stick to the script we’re looking for fairly well.

What Perfumes are Similar to Romance by Ralph Lauren?

Romantic Affair

Her Affair by Dua Brand– The first entry will be a fragrance that is inspired by the notes of Romance, rather than most others on the list which are just similar to what we’re looking for.

Her Affair is going to try and hit the same beats of the Ralph Lauren scent, all presented in an extrait de parfum concentration.

Ginger, lemon, rose, lily, and musk are all here. This is the one to get, if you want a cheaper alternative to our target scent. I haven’t tried this one, but I have bought a bunch of others from this brand, which have been on point.

Lighter on the Rose Perfume

Dazzling Gold by Estee Lauder– The rose in Dazzling Gold, is very light, and only detectable for a short time. However, it shares the lily, freesia, and other floral notes.

Dazzling Gold isn’t one of the more well known Estee Lauder fragrances, but it fits in to the sort of scent we’re trying to capture with Romance. The fruity notes are there, but serve as background players, You get apple, berries, and some litchi sweetness.

A Close Comparison

Feminin Pluriel– This fragrance from Maison Francis Kurkdjian is a really close alternative to Romance. The main difference is the additional iris note, which gives it more of a powdery finish than the Ralph Lauren.

Also, this one can be much more expensive, and isn’t as widely available. On the plus side, it has a cleaner profile, and feels a bit more elegant than our target scent.

The More Floral Alternative

Very Irresistible by Givenchy– Is this Givenchy scent an exact copy of Romance? No, and, it really isn’t a cheaper alternative either.  What it is, is a perfume that sits in the same scent family as the Ralph Lauren.

It’s floral, without the fruity highlights of Romance, but with some nice added spice from notes like anise. You do get the great rose note, but it goes a bit different in the other floral ingredients, magnolia and peony.

Very Irresistible is a very energetic and versatile floral, for those who want to go in a similar but somewhat different direction than Romance.

The Cheaper Alternative

Sabaya by Al-Rehab– Al-Rehab is a brand that has plenty of great options, which are similar to very popular fragrances. Sabaya, closely mimics the aroma of Romance, but with more citrus in the profile.

You still get a nice rose note, a great freshness, and the citrus. The citrus is actually pretty heavy up top but it settles down later on. Is it better than Romance? No, but this is a much cheaper option, than can usually be had for under $20.

A Sweeter Floral

Elie Saab Le Parfum Eau De Parfum Spray for Women, 3 Ounce– An original perfume from the Elie Saab line that has spawned a ton of flankers of itself. Le Parfum is a very feminine floral highlighted by jasmine and orange blossom. Quite the springtime, traditional floral perfume.

Elie Saab Le Parfum kicks off with a large dose of the orange blossom, that is then paired with, honey and patchouli. It’s of course sweet and floral, with a rose note beginning to creep into the picture.

However, the rose never quite catches on completely. Instead, you get jasmine and orange blossom occupying the top. Underneath that, is: patchouli, honey, and a cedar base. Great sillage, with 7-9 hour range of wear. Le Parfum Review

6 Perfumes Similar to Alien Goddess

by

Alien Goddess has become a very popular flanker spun off from the extremely popular original Alien perfume from Mugler. Maybe its the coconut water or something else that people are into, but it just works.

However, you may want something a little different from Alien Goddess or Alien Goddess Intense. You might like aspects of that perfume, but not the entire thing. Or, you want something nearly identical for cheaper. Or, a similar style. In any case, this is the page where I will keep track of all the options that smell like Alien Goddess.

What Fragrances Smell Like or are Similar to Alien Goddess?

alien goddess review

Floral Swap

Metallique by Tom Ford– Right off the bat, this isn’t the same as Goddess. But, between it and Goddess Intense this does have much of the same note structure. Just different weightings and different effects.

Still, if you like Goddess the style of this Tom Ford perfume should appeal to you. Bright and cold aldehydes kick things off alongside the same bergamot and pink pepper notes that are found in the Mugler’s.

Heliotrope is also here. However, Metallique feels like more of a general floral blend that is paried with the musk, amber, and aldehydes. None of the tropical aspects are here without the coconut. But, you get a creamy vanilla and sandalwood in the base, that picks up the slack.

Famous Similarities

Fame by Paco Rabanne– Fame or Fame Parfum do have a good deal of overlap with the Goddess series. Fame Parfum is the better of the two Paco Rabanne scents, but I like Goddess Intense the best of all of them.

Instead of the coconut water found in Alien Goddess, we get mango. The tropical aroma and the floral aspects of these fragrances are similar, but not the same.

Jasmine, vanilla, and sandalwood are strong in the EDP version of Fame. The tropical aroma, doesn’t last long.

With Fame Parfum, you get a longer time with the mango and some fresh spice with pink pepper. The dry down with the jasmine and sandalwood also feels smoother. Not a replica of Alien Goddess, but inhabits the same style.

Cristal Connection

La Vie est Belle Soleil Cristal by Lancome– This is another one that has a pretty similar style and smell to Alien Goddess without being the same. It, Fame, and Goddess all inhabit the same category with differences in their blends. Maybe, Bronze by Ellen Tracy too.

With Soleil Cristal, you get a sparkling opening of citrus and coconut notes. It’s bright and lively without feeling like a sugary bomb.

I get some spice and more of the coconut note here, than the vanilla. Less creamy, with a fresher dynamic. Iris and ylang-ylang are the background supporters to the coconut and vanilla notes, clean with some powdery highlights.

I like this one, not fantastic, but can give you a slightly different look and mix than what the Mugler perfume offers. Soleil Cristal review

soleil cristal review

Rose, Coconut, Vanilla

La Nuit Tresor Nude by Lancôme– One that is like our target, but the big difference is in the floral note used. Rose versus the signature jasmine of the Alien series.

La Nuit Tresor Nude actually makes the strange pairing of rose and coconut work. How? Well, it’s more focused on the sweet and creamy notes than it is the floral. The rose is prominent in the dry down, when the vanilla starts coming through.

Early? Sweet and lotion-like coconut and the same bergamot as in Alien Goddess. But, it’s stronger in this Lancôme scent. I think this might be discontinued, but as of now its still plenty available online, if you’re interested.

Goddess Intense Sort of Smell

Donna Born in Roma Intense– This Valentino fragrance is more akin to Goddess Intense than the original Alien Goddess. Intense has a subdued bergamot citrus, less powder than the original, and a more substantial coconut.

Well, Born in Roma Intense doesn’t have the bergamot or coconut. However, the jasmine, amber, benzoin, and vanilla notes are all here.

To me, this is sweeter over the duration than is Intense. It doesn’t have the same level of soapiness in the dry down. Also, this one is more vanilla heavy than I get with the Mugler. After all, it doesn’t have the coconut.

No real price break is to be had. So, I’d probably go with this if you’re not a big fan of the coconut note, but like the idea of the rest of Alien Goddess Intense.

Ylang-Ylang Option

Replica Beach Walk– This Maison Margiela perfume isn’t exactly the same as Goddess, which may be a good thing. Here, you get a lot of overlap with it and Goddess Intense. But, there’s no jasmine.

Instead, that floral note is swapped out with a great ylang-ylang. The similarities are in the notes, but not necessarily how they’re constructed. Here, the scent feels more lotion-like, more like a salty beach day than the probably more well put together Mugler.

Personally, I’d go with the Alien Goddess series versus this one. But, this can be a viable alternative for people who still want the citrus, coconut, benzoin, and the like of the Mugler…just remixed into a different smell.