Armaf Club de Nuit Intense vs. Dior Sauvage

Two of the best selling fragrances for men right now, came about reaching that status in different ways. Sauvage EDT really propelled the ambroxan heavy mass appealing scent into the mainstream. So much so that it is the best selling fragrance (for men or women) in the world. Meanwhile Club de Nuit Intense, got to where it is by being an inexpensively priced and similar scent to Creed’s famous Aventus. Now, each of these are two of the last colognes that some men often need to decide between to purchase. Which one is actually the better choice?

---

Tale of the Tape: Club de Nuit Intense vs. Sauvage EDT

Sauvage

Notes of Sauvage: bergamot, ambroxan, lavender, pepper, wood notes

Click here to try: Christian Dior Sauvage for Men Eau De Toilette Spray, 3.4 Fluid Ounce

My Original Sauvage Review

---

Club de Nuit EDP

Notes include: lemon, apple, blackcurrant, birch, jasmine, rose, vanilla, musk, ambergris, patchouli

Click here to try: Club de Nuit Men EDP

---

Opening

Luckily for this post (not so much for my other work), I was accidently sent a new sample vial of Dior Sauvage EDT, instead of the Eau Sauvage the brand has been producing since the 1960s.

So, I have both of these fragrances on hand in order to compare them directly, instead of just off of past experience.

Club de Nuit EDP is very similar to the EDT release, which smells a lot like Aventus. It’s fruity, less smoky, and the birch comes across as more of a dry wood, without the same amount of leathery facets it will develop later.

To me, the EDP comes across as being a bit smoother. Less of the lemon note, but with a more pronounced apple, which I enjoy.  Also, the birch here is smokier early on and does give it that leathery aroma to a greater extent.

The opening of Sauvage gives off an aroma of amber, pepper, and the bergamot note. There is a bit of spice to it but I do get a lot of the ambroxan. It’s nice and dries down to a clean/soapy scent with some slightly spice wood notes and the bergamot.

One thing I notice with this Sauvage EDT sample, is that the bergamot doesn’t seem as sharp when paired with the Sichuan pepper, as it has in the past.

Actually, it’s much smoother than it has been on me before and more so than Club de Nuit Intense.

I’ve never been a fan of the opening act of Aventus and don’t particularly care too much about its cheaper alternative’s either. So, this category is going to go to Sauvage.

Edge: Sauvage

---

Projection

The sillage for both is very good. You get a very good scent trail coming off of the skin for hours on end, before it settles into something more intimate.

I’m not sure that there is much of a difference between Sauvage and Club de Nuit Intense EDP. Maybe it’d be noticeable with the full bottle sprayers, but with these sample sprayers, 3-4 sprays come across as being the same.

Perhaps, Sauvage’s projection reach stays around for a tad longer, but it’s not clear to me that it actually does.

Edge: Push

---

Longevity

With Sauvage EDT, it’s always lasted between 6-8 hours on my skin. But, it will usually be closer to the 8 hour end of things.

Club de Nuit Intense EDP will go for 7-9 hours. So, a higher floor and a bit better ceiling, in terms of how long it will last.

Not a massive difference and some might get better performance with the Dior. For me, the nod goes to the Armaf.

Edge: Club de Nuit

---

Versatility

Both are extremely versatile as to when you can wear them. Seasonally, I’d give the edge to Club in the autumn/winter and Sauvage in spring/summer.

Neither is great in the high heat, and actually, I’d use something else in the extreme cold as well. But, Sauvage does perform a bit better in the warmer weather, while still having the ability to be used in the colder months.

Both are good casually, out at night, etc. Neither is much of a formal fragrance. Club is probably better than Sauvage in dressier situations, but it doesn’t have the same Creed quality as with Aventus to make that certain.

Really, this category is kind of equal.

Edge: Push

---

Overall Scent

Overall, which one of these fragrances do I prefer?

With Sauvage EDT, it’s never been one that I loved. I liked it when it came out, got completely sick of it for years, and now…it’s fine. Doesn’t bother me, but I don’t really enjoy wearing it that much. I get the appeal, but it’s just nothing all that special.

By the same token, I’ve never been an Aventus fan boy. I like it more than Sauvage EDT, find it nice to wear on occasion, but I don’t personally need to have it around.

If I had to pick between the original Sauvage EDT and one of the Club de Nuit Intense options, I’d go with the Armaf. I do prefer the mimicry of Creed Aventus a bit more than that particular Sauvage release.

Plus, Armaf is significantly cheaper than what you’re going to spend versus Dior.

However, if I can choose any version of Sauvage, the decision would definitely change for me. Here’s what the list would look like then:

1a. Sauvage Elixir

1b. Sauvage EDP

2. Sauvage Parfum

3. Club de Nuit Intense EDP

4. Club de Nuit Intense EDT

5. Sauvage EDT

So, it’s really only when compared to the original Sauvage formulation, do I have a preference for the Armaf colognes. I really do like Sauvage EDP and Elixir provides a unique experience versus all of them.

Winner: Club de Nuit