Guerlain L’Homme Ideal EDT vs. EDP

Guerlain Ideal has become a very popular line for the French brand over the past near decade. I’ve like aspects of all the releases that I’ve come across and think that they are definitely worthwhile colognes to try. Albeit, I do personally feel they’re overrated. Nonetheless, two of the more sought out options are L’Homme Ideal EDT and the eau de parfum. In this post, I want to compare them head to head, before declaring an ultimate winner in the contest.

---

Tale of the Tape: L’Homme Ideal EDT vs. EDP

Ideal EDT

Notes include: grapefruit, bergamot, orange, almond, musk, pink pepper, musk, neroli

Click here to try: Guerlain L’Homme Ideal Cologne EDT Spray for Men, 3.3 Ounce

Read my review: Ideal EDT

---

Ideal EDP

Notes include: cherry, almond, lavender, vanilla, incense, rose, rosemary, leather, tonka bean, and more

Click here to try: L’Homme Ideal EDP at Selfridges (ships from UK)

Read my full review: Ideal EDP

---

Opening

The original Ideal EDT opens up with its blend of almond and woody spice coming through. It’s nutty and has its fresh citrus notes coming through along with the smoothness of the leather.

Nutty with a citrus and leathery finish.

Meanwhile, Ideal EDP goes with a natural cherry and almond blend. The opening features some spiciness, but it is overall smooth just like the EDT. Leather, vanilla, and other warmer hints are coming through from the base.

The opening is very much like Ideal L’Intense, just with the spices/smokiness toned way down and a much sweeter scent in comparison.

Which is better? For me, it is actually pretty close. I like the way EDT starts and kind of prefer it to EDP, even though I enjoy the cherry note.

Edge: EDT

---

Projection

Sillage wise, both of these fragrances hit the moderate band on my skin. You might think the higher eau de parfum concentration might give it a higher boost, but that hasn’t ever seemed to be the case.

Wearing them, I don’t particularly notice a difference with how well they project, or when I happen to spray each on clothing. No clear winner here.

Edge: Push

---

Longevity

Both of these have pretty nice longevity, even if they are the best projecting fragrances out there. With L’Homme Ideal EDT, I can get 4-6.5 hours from it depending on the day.

EDP is a bit better, in this regard. I will usually get 8 hours and it can last on my skin for up to 9.5, under the right conditions.

EDP actually takes this category fairly easily. Ideal EDT, just doesn’t have that level of perfomance.

Edge: EDP

---

Versatility

Seasonally, these two colognes pretty much hit opposite ends. With Ideal EDT, it is a complete spring and summertime wear. It’s an awesome warmer weather wear.

EDP is all about the autumn and winter. On a crisp winter evening, it is fantastic.

Neither really serves as an all-around one size fits all fragrance. EDT does strike me as a bit more casual and better suited for the daytime. EDP feels like it could venture better into more formal situations, light enough for office wear, and can be a nighttime gem.

Edge: EDP

---

Overall Scent

Overall, I enjoy wearing both of these scents. There actually isn’t a wide gap at all between them, in my experience and which I’d prefer to wear.

I love the citrus and almond blend of the original EDT. It fits so well in the summer months and while not a complete beast, it has good enough performance. The dry down is fresh and pleasant.

But, I think that the EDP is a touch ahead of the EDT. The cherry not up top, with the leather refinement, and subtle depth of the overall composition brings more to the table than the EDT. You get improved performance and some more versatile wearing options.

Again, not a massive win, but a win nonetheless. I actually think I prefer the discontinued Ideal Cologne to both of them.

One more factor that I’d like to mention is the availability in the US. Ideal EDP isn’t sold here anymore, outside of places like eBay. As such, you’ll probably have to order from the UK. That means, you might be paying $30+ for shipping costs.

Is Ideal EDP, worth that amount? Ehhh, maybe not. Unless you really want a bottle, I would just consider buying the much more affordable EDT. EDP is the better fragrance, but can be a pain to acquire.

Winner: Ideal EDP