Joop! vs. 1 Million Fragrance Comparison

In this edition of the head to head men’s fragrances match up, I want to do a comparison of two nightlife colognes, from different eras. The late 80s beast, Joop! Homme vs. 1 Million, which has been a champ over the past decade-plus. Which of these scents smells better? Which lasts longer? Has better sillage? Is the better buy overall?

---

Tale of the Tape

1 Million

Notes include: Mint, Grapefruit, Rose, Patchouli, Amber, Cinnamon, White woods, Blond leather, Blood orange, Spice notes

Click here to try: Paco Rabanne 1 Million By Paco Rabanne For Men Edt Spray, 3.4 Ounce

Read my review: 1 Million

---

Joop! Homme

Notes include: orange blossom, vanilla, cinnamon, mandarin, amber, cedar, jasmine, bergamot, lily, heliotrope, tonka bean, patchouli, and sandalwood

Click here to try:  Joop Pour Homme Eau de Toilette Spray for Men, 4.2 Fluid Ounce

Read my review: Joop!

---

Opening

1 Million is pretty notorious for its bold opening act (as well as the rest of it). It jumps out at you with a blend of blood orange, grapefruit, mint, rose, and smooth leather.

It’s got some spicy elements with the mint and cinnamon, but overall it is warm and sweet, with an amber coating. Mainly, the cinnamon will stick out. More of a warm spice than the colder freshness.

Joop! Pour Homme is also bold, from the start. It goes toward the spicier end of things, with plenty of cinnamon and patchouli, leading things off.

Those are the dominant notes, with amber, some light citrus, and floral notes peaking in from underneath.

Here the spice is more intense than it is in the Paco Rabanne. Joop! has a thicker near syrupy aroma, at times.

Which is better? I prefer how 1 Million starts versus Joop. It has a better aroma, that is sweeter, and more complex. I do like the spice of Joop, but it can also be too much for some people.

Edge: 1 Million

---

Projection

The sillage of both of these scents is pretty legendary. But which takes the crown? In my experience, it is 1 Million.

The current variations of Joop are still very powerful, but may have lost a step versus the vintage. Either way, I think the Paco Rabanne, has always been a bit ahead.

Update: 1 Million is still strong. However, it’s not as strong as it once was, and that peak is shorter lived. I’m flipping this category to Joop!

Edge: Joop!

---

Longevity

Joop can for between 7-9 hours, on my skin, depending on the climate of the day. Meanwhile, 1 Million again is a beast, and has gotten me 10+ hours on a regular basis always.

Update: Newer bottles of 1 Million will last arond 8 hours. As such, there’s no longer an advantage here. Let’s change it to a tie.

Edge: Push

---

Versatility

1 Million and Joop are both best for colder weather and nightlife. Both being loud and sort of monstrous in their sillage, aren’t that great of choices for business environments.

Having said that, I think that 1 Million is slightly better, in warmer conditions than is Joop. Plus, it tends to be more universally appealing and accepted than it’s competitor.

Joop can be very polarizing for people. It’s not for the faint of heart and there’s a ton of people who don’t like it.

Edge: 1 Million

Overall Scent

Alright, this was a pretty easy win for 1 Million. However, I will say that I do actually like Joop! Homme. I know, it can be one that makes people fall into a love/hate relationship, but it does still have its moments of brilliance.

It’ll just never be a ‘safe’ choice. I’ve gotten both extremely positive and negative reactions while wearing it (mostly the early stage spice, hits folks noses hard). It dates back to another era, but can still be a great cheapie, in certain situations.

1 Million is just better smelling and while it doesn’t perform the same, it’s still quite good for an EDT. Add to that, its mass appeal, and you have why it’s been a best seller for a long time now.

It is a superior fragrance to Joop! Homme and I would rather wear it versus that, in almost every scenario, even with my soft spot for Joop.

Winner: 1 Million