Polo Blue EDT vs EDP Cologne Comparison

by

Given my recent wear and review of Polo Blue EDP, I thought that I should do a comparison between that fragrance and the original Polo Blue EDT. While there is plenty of overlap between these two Ralph Lauren scents, the EDP does have a slightly different profile which gives it a distinction versus the Eau de Toilette. Which one smells better? Performs better? Is worth a purchase? Continue below for my thoughts.

Polo Blue EDT vs EDP: Which is Better?

Polo Blue Tale of the Tape

Notes include: amber, melon, patchouli, geranium, cucumber, tangerine, moss, musk

Click here to try: Polo Blue by Ralph Lauren for Men, Eau De Toilette Natural Spray, 4.2 Ounce

Read my original review: Polo Blue Review

Polo Blue EDP Tale of the Tape

Notes include: suede, bergamot, cardamom, basil, sea notes, sage, vetiver, woods

Click here to try: R.L. Polo Blue 4.2 oz / 125 ml Eau De Parfum EDP for Men

Read my original review: Polo Blue EDP Review

polo blue edp

Opening

The original Polo Blue EDT is a fresh and crisp experience highlighted by the cucumber and melon notes. To me, that cologne always felt pretty bland, especially in the beginning of the wear.

You get those watery and crisp fruits with some light citrus. Then, the sage and basil ingredients, are seriously toned down when compared to the eau de parfum. I will say, it is fresh and I’ve grown to like it a bit more than I previously had, especially that hint of smooth suede.

Meanwhile, the EDP version strikes me as a blend of the EDT and Acqua Di Gio Profumo. The bergamot note leads off and gives it a citrus aroma to go along with the spice.

Eau de Parfum has much more character than the original and even if I’m not blown away by either, I prefer the EDP. It feels a little bit darker, more intense, and just more substantial.

Again, I’ve like Blue EDT more recently, than I had in the past. But, I’ll still go with the EDP for this category.

Edge: EDP

Projection

Both are moderate in how well they project. However, I will say that the EDP is a bit stronger than the original, but not by much. Still, I do notice a difference between them.

None of the scents from the Polo Blue lineup are powerhouses, with their sillage, and overall ability to project themselves in a room.

Edge: EDP

Longevity

Either one of these lasts in the 7-8 hour range usually. The EDP might have a slight advantage due to the strength of the bergamot note, but it’s basically even.

The line of Blue fragrances from Polo have all been pretty darn good on my skin. The Red’s have been more all over the map, but these seem to be pretty consistent across the board.

Edge: Push

Versatility

Both are casual and warmer weather scents. I actually think that the EDP has fit in quite well during these winter months, so I’ll give it the edge. Again, it’s not a huge difference.

Both colognes can be worn on a daily basis, but I think they feel more casual, than being office scents. You can wear them out, but they aren’t club bangers.

Edge: EDP

Overall

I think that the EDP is an improvement on the original. The initial similarities with Acqua Di Gio Profumo is a nice addition, as is the later enhanced suede and sea notes, that make the Eau de Parfum feel much more defined.

The original Polo Blue was a decent smelling and performing fragrance, I just found it pretty boring. The EDP on the other hand, has gained some points in its favor, and I actually quite like it.

Plus, I have found that I can usually buy a cheap bottle of Eternity Aqua, which is a near clone of the EDT version and get the same experience for less.

It’s still not my favorite scent but I have found myself wearing the sample a lot over the past few weeks and think that it’s a good buy for those who like citrus/aquatic/woodsy parfums.

Update: I would also put forward, the new release, Polo Deep Blue. It settles into something like a midpoint between the EDT and EDP, but with an interesting opening act of mango and marine notes.

Ranking the Blue releases, I’d have Deep Blue at number one. EDP at number 2. Gold Blend at 3. I have a bottle of Gold Blend, that I got for cheap, and I’d put it a notch below the other two.

Update 2: Both of those fragrances are discontinued. Gold Blend got annoying after some time. I’d still go with Blue eau de parfum as of 2025 versus EDT and the newer Parfum.

gold blend review

Winner: Polo Blue EDP

Afternoon Swim by Louis Vuitton

by

Afternoon Swim is going to be the first full review that I’ve done of a Louis Vuitton scent, on the site. I’ve got decants of most of the releases and will work my way through them over the coming weeks and months.

This one was brought to market in 2019 as a part of the Les Colognes Louis Vuitton series. What does it smell like? When should it be worn? Is it worth a try?

What does Afternoon Swim by Louis Vuitton Smell like?

Notes include: bergamot, mandarin orange, orange, ginger, ambergris

My Full Review

Before I get into my personal review, let’s see what Louis Vuitton has to say about Afternoon Swim: Passionate orange, to sail toward pleasure. A plunge into an ocean of sensations. Feeling all the energy of the waves washing over the skin on a hot summer’s day.

Alright, so from the start, just know that this isn’t a very complex fragrance. It’s also heavily weighted to citrus notes, so, if that’s not your thing try another Vuitton perfume.

Afternoon Swim kicks off with its orange notes front and center. I do smell mandarin, but another orange seems to have the upper hand, and there’s also a solid dose of bergamot.

It reminds me quite a bit of Dior Homme Cologne or Allure Homme Sport Cologne by Chanel, just with different citrus notes, and more ginger. Less spicy and resinous than the Chanel. 

I like the addition of the ginger note, as it gives Swim a bit more heft than just being another thin and quick citrus scent. It’s also one of my favorite spices, so it really grabs my attention.

The other scent that I am reminded of is, Millesime Imperial by Creed. That one and this LV fragrance both have an ambergris note, at the base, but it is much lighter here.

Personally, I love a good summer citrus fragrance, and this one is a great example. Bright, juicy, and full of vibrancy. Very much like being at the pool or walking a seaside promenade during the warmer months.

As it moves along, I get more of the bergamot on my skin versus the orange note and just enough of the ambergris to add a touch of saltiness to the composition. 

That’s pretty much what the tail end of this fragrance is all about.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Most of the time, these sort of colognes aren’t powerhouses. Afternoon Swim, included. It’s on the lighter end of moderate and will project 4-6 feet from the skin, at its peak, before drawing closer and closer.

Though, this Vuitton wasn’t a complete skin scent until later in the wear. It has enough substance to keep bringing wafts of the aroma for a good while.

On my skin, it stuck around for 5-6 hours. Not amazing or any type of marathon runner. Though, again, to be expected with a summer citrus splash. But, at this price, you might be of the mind that you want more out of it.

Afternoon Swim is a safe to wear unisex scent. I’d keep it to the daytime, mostly in summer, but it’s great here in spring too.

Not going to be a nightlife, club banger, or sexy sort of scent. Probably not a bad choice for a pool or beach party, though.

A super fresh and fruity scent that  energizes and can be a lot of fun to wear.

Wear it casually or semi-formally when the temperatures start to rise, in your neck of the woods. This is one that I loved wearing outside, over the summer. Just at the beach, boardwalk, or other more vacation mode type of activities.

 

 

Overall Impressions of Afternoon Swim

Do I like this fragrance? I do. I like it a lot, in fact.

I really enjoy these citrus colognes for the summer months and this one gives me some really juicy orange notes. Orange is usually one of my least favorite citrus notes in fragrances, but the pair are great, along with bergamot.

It’s not a scent that is going to be overly complicated or even a signature wear for anyone. But, if you want a great summer wear that can hold up well in the heat, Afternoon Swim can deliver.

For the type and style that this perfume is, Afternoon Swim is pretty fantastic. It has a much more limited use case, but is a very nice wear within that.

Is it worth the price? I don’t know that I’d reach for this, if Louis Vuitton prices are a stretch for you budget.

Again, you can get similar results from Dior Homme Cologne, which is more affordable. It’s not the same, it’s simpler, but might be a fine alternative.

Update: The Dua Brand has its version of Afternoon Swim, called Gone Swimming. I personally purchased their blended version of this Louis Vuitton with their version of Virgin Island Water…and it’s fantastic.

If you want the Louis Vuitton experience, at a cheaper price and with better performance, I highly recommend getting a hold of one of the Dua versions. Gone Swimming in Caribbean Waters is amazing and will be one of my go to fragrances in the summer.

Uomo Born in Roma Coral Fantasy by Valentino

by

Valentino has released its latest fragrance from its Born in Roma line for men. 2022’s scent is called Coral Fantasy, with its juice resembling the color with its pinkish hue. This is the third cologne in the Roma series. How does it smell? When should it be worn? Is it worth a try?

What does Uomo Coral Fantasy Smell Like?

Notes include: red apple, tobacco, patchouli, sage, geranium

Click here to try: Coral Fantasy from Saks

My Full Review

Here’s how Valentino describes it: Inspired by the light of Rome at sunset, Uomo Born in Roma Coral Fantasy is an amber, fruity men’s fragrance composed of a colorful apple accord. Blended with smoky tobacco, this eau de toilette is infused with a heart of sage and germanium essence to reveal a powerful yet fresh cologne.

Tried it yourself? Leave your own review and score in the comments below.

I never ended up trying out Born in Roma Yellow Dream, as the original Born in Roma, is one of the few fragrances that I had a bad reaction to. Stuff makes me dizzy as hell. But, when I read the notes to Coral Fantasy, I wanted to give it a go.

I actually thought about blind buying a full bottle of this to test out, but instead found 3 sample vials for sale on eBay. It turned out to be a good call, as I don’t think I’d actually want a full bottle of Coral Fantasy.

The fragrance does open up with a pretty interesting aroma. The crisp red apple note is the star, with it sweet and juicy scent getting paired early on with cardamom and some spices.

It actually reminds me of a cider, that I’ve had before. But, with a bit of a sweeter kick.

That red apple note is great with the cardamom and bergamot, lending some warmth a slight lemon-like fruitiness of its own with the spice.  The first spray does give Coral Fantasy a warmer amber feel to it, but that’s not how it finishes.

Sage is the third player in the early stages behind the cardamom and apple. I get a nice burst of it at the very start, which will hold through the first transition.

That transition does come on early. The initial fruitiness will begin to fade, making way for the next phase. Geranium freshness will permeate, the lavender and tobacco notes will begin to show up, and the red apple will be a role player.

I actually do get some comparison to Spicebomb Night Vision EDT. Not the same, the Valentino is better, but there is overlap between them.

At this point, it is a colder, drier, freshness.  A geranium, sage, lavender trio will then morph into a geranium and tobacco scent with hints of patchouli and vetiver coming up from the base.

Tobacco is the note that hangs around. It ends up cold, slightly sweet, with a earthy sort of freshness. Patchouli and geranium also stick it out a bit, at the very end.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Sillage wise, you can call this a moderate. It doesn’t overpower. That first hour or so, will create a nice scent bubble around you, but it will weaken. Much of the wear, it is a skin scent on me.

Perhaps, you’ll have better luck?

It does stick on the skin for a decent amount of time, even in that weakened state. I could still pick up the tobacco note about 7 hours in. Not great, but serviceable for an eau de toilette.

Seasonally, I’d wear this anytime outside of the summer months. It works in colder temperatures, but best in this early spring weather or even in the autumn. So, one should get plenty of use out of it.

It could be worn in a wide variety of situations. Maybe not the most formal cologne or a club banger, but beyond that, it should be fine.

Really any age could wear this one. The opening does have a more youthful vibe, but it never strays too far that way, quickly snapped back by the tobacco note.

roma coral fantasy review

Overall Impressions of Uomo Coral Fantasy

Overall, do I like this scent? Coral Fantasy is pretty good, but not great. I don’t think it is a terrible cologne, but it doesn’t for the most part, grab my attention. I like aspects of it, just the overall presentation never hits a super high level.

The opening is where you’re going to get the sweetness and the most unique aspect of this fragrance. When that’s going on and when you get the pairing of the apple remnants with the tobacco note, this Valentino is enjoyable.

After that, it’s fine and I don’t dislike it. The geranium, tobacco, and overall freshness is nice. Though, it is also kind of weak with its sillage. A decent few hours of performance, before becoming fairly mediocre.

I wanted to like Coral Fantasy more than I actually do. The notes sounded intriguing enough to me that I almost purchased a full bottle. Personally, I probably wouldn’t have gotten much use out of that.

That being said, I do think that it’s worth a try. Maybe not at full retail price, but with a significant discount, it could be a nice pick up for certain guys. This is one you should test out and see if it actually speaks to you.

Polo Red EDT by Ralph Lauren

by

Ralph Lauren has become synonymous with American style. The companies’ designs are clean, classic, and often times colorful. Beyond the world of clothing, Ralph Lauren Polo enjoys also enjoys great success in the fragrance realm. For decades now, the firm has put out colognes and perfumes that perform and smell great.

Polo Red has been one that they’ve relied on for the past decade or so, spawning a ton of flanker scents, which have become somewhat popular in their own right. But, how does it smell? Perform? Is it worth a try?

What does Polo Red Smell Like?

polo red

Notes include: grapefruit, italian lemon, cranberry, saffron, sage, coffee beans, and amber

Click here to try: POLO RED by Ralph Lauren, 4.2 Fl Oz

My Full Take on Polo Red

Sweet, warm, with spice is how I would describe this fragrance in short. This is not a girly type of sweetness like candy or something, rather, the citrus notes produce an alluring scent rooted in the masculine.

I think that there is a certain energy that comes with smelling Polo Red, sort of a refreshing blast that transitions into a moderate fragrance enveloped in a warm glow. It is a seductive cologne which maintains a classy air, subtle yet one which the ladies are sure to enjoy.

It opens with a mix of citrus and cranberry. This pairing is quite sharp and very sweet from the jump. The citrus contingent is led by Italian lemon with some added grapefruit. It opens up with a super bright disposition and of course that tart cranberry note.

Cranberry is the main attraction here, so, keep that in mind if you’re thinking about giving Polo Red a try…you have to like that note to enjoy.

Underneath those three fruity notes, is amber, which provides that warm cloud wrapping around the sweetness.

A few minutes after the sharp/tart opening, the edge is taken off by the amber and the sweetness then takes on a slight bubble gum aroma. Not too overt or anything, but it is the sort of vibe that I pick up on.

The Italian lemon note, I think, adds a different kind of feeling from many other colognes on the market. Versace Eros, also has Italian lemon as one of its notes and the two are somewhat similar, though Eros has a much heavier projection and woodsy feel to it.

There is a coffee bean note listed here, but I’ve never gotten that smell. Polo Red Extreme has the coffee note ramped up, but in the original, it is absent for me.

Saffron and sage are present, particularly the former, which brings some depth of character and a bit of spice. Finally, there is a bit of random wood note in the base. Not much.

So, most of what you’re getting with Polo Red is: tart cranberry, citrus, warm sweetness, with some light spice and wood. Lots of cranberry and lemon, sitting on a sea of amber. It really does evoke a sense of ‘red’.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Projection wise, Polo Red starts off somewhat intensely for me, before it settles down quite a bit into a subtle and moderate fragrance. Some people report that the longevity is a problem but I find it to be so-so in that regard.

Some days, it feels like it lasts quite adequately while other times it gives out too quickly. I’ve tried out doubling up on how much I apply and this works well to boost the longevity.

I’ve gotten anywhere from 4-7 hours, with this cologne over the years. It is kind of strange, its varied outcomes, but it’s usually in line with the other Ralph Lauren colognes.

You don’t need to go overboard but a little more wouldn’t hurt. I currently have a splash mini bottle and I have to go fairly heavy. So, initially Polo Red is radiating from my skin, and then settles down. This definitely isn’t a heavy scent but it does provide a warm cloud of fragrance.

I like this one for the springtime, mostly, although it wouldn’t feel completely out of place during other months of the year. It’s better in colder temperatures, than high humidity, and heat.

Polo Red is a very nice choice for an everyday casual wear and it can be versatile enough for other occasions. It isn’t going to be a formal fragrance, though. Probably not one, you’d want to wear in a more serious office environment.

It’s sweet fruity aroma, will skew more towards the younger set. If I were want a Polo Red fragrance as an older guy, I’d be picking up Extreme.

Overall Impressions of Polo Red

Is Polo Red a good cologne? Yes. I really like this fragrance and it seems that others do as well. It can be somewhat pricey and as such I think it should have better longevity. However, if one grabs a small 0.5 oz bottle for cheap, it would be worth it to wear now and again.

They did just release Polo Red Intense which amps up the qualities of this fragrance but I have yet to try it (Update here is my comparison: Red vs. Intense). Good stuff, but it might be worth getting the Intense version instead now.

Newer Update: I liked this stuff more years ago. It was one of the earlier one’s I enjoyed, when I first started the site in 2013. As of now, I’m not all that high on it. I still do like aspects of Red.

For instance, the cranberry tartness is still pretty unique, paired with that amber glow. Still, I’d pick Polo Red Extreme over this. Depending on my feeling that day on Intense, the original Polo Red EDT, ranks either second or the more usual third out of this series.

It’s fun and fairly attractive. Not the most versatile wear, in terms of age range and occasion, but you can still get good use out of it.

YSL Opium Pour Homme EDT

by

One of the first colognes that I ever bought for myself was Opium Pour Homme eau de toilette by Yves Saint Laurent. I remember that I had read positive reviews on the fragrance, but I think what swung me to buying it, was the name. Yes, as stupid as that sounds I simply liked the name, Opium.

It made the cologne sound exotic and addictive to me, which were two qualities that I thought would work well in a fragrance. Opium was introduced by YSL in 1995. In this post, I want to cover how it smells, what the notes are, how long it lasts, and whether or not it is worth a try.

What does Opium Pour Homme Smell Like?

opium

Notes in Opium Pour Homme: Vanilla, ginger, pepper, cedar, black currant, star anise, and balsam

Click here to try: Opium for Men Eau De Toilette by Yves Saint Laurent 3.4 oz

Full Review of Opium EDT

Note: I am reviewing a bottle that I bought in the mid-2000s, on this page and updating it. I did recently purchase one of the last batches that was produced. I don’t recommend getting one of these newer bottles, as it just feels weak and watered down. Unfortunately, it is absolutely gutted in comparison to its vintage formula and not very good.

Opium Pour Homme EDT opens up with a blast of warm spice and a sharp but mellowed black currant. The black currant note is fruity and juicy but is really only noticeable at the top, quickly fading into the background.

Immediately, one is going to notice the presence of balsam, and how its thick warmth envelops the entire composition of Opium. To me, that’s what gives this cologne its whole, ethereal and exotic feel.

It can sometimes seem too concentrated when fresh out of the bottle but it quickly settles and exposes the underlying notes which give it its intoxicating power. This happens when the black currant fades and the spices take hold over more of the scent.

Star anise, pepper, and I also believe that ginger is in the mix as well; this trio provides an Oriental spice and freshness to what otherwise could become a warm almost medicinal mess.

As it dries down further, Opium takes on a sweeter aroma, thanks to the classic vanilla. Vanilla wrapped in that same balsamic note and sitting on top of a cedar base.

It feels somewhat woody, but it is mostly all about that vanilla/balsam combo and the spice (mostly anise, at this point). The cedar does provide more substance here and allows the other notes to do their thing.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Projection wise, the sillage of the mid-2000s bottle that I have, was really quite heavy at first before settling down to a more moderate wear. Upon first applying it is going to be pretty loud and somewhat harsh, with a rather large radius off fragrance surrounding you.

The longevity was always really good too. I’m not sure if the newer bottles have been reformulated (it might even be discontinued?), but I could get 7-8+ hours of wear out of the EDT, without any problem. 

Update: With this newest bottle, the longevity and power isn’t there to the same extent. A step below for sure. Again, it’s no longer produced from what I can tell, but the last run wasn’t great.

I like to wear Opium mostly in the daytime as I feel it is a perfect complement to casual environments. It is still a captivating fragrance however and routinely draws complements from others including perfect strangers.

Yes, it is bold enough to go into the nightlife, also. Seasonally, it is a cold weather cologne, all the way. Don’t bother wearing this in the heat, as it can get messy. However, in the cold, it is utterly great.

There are certain fragrances on the market that cater to the sensibilities of the younger man, though, I don’t believe this is one of them. That’s not to say it is an old man’s fragrance, it just has a certain sophistication that many of the more fruity based colognes lack.

This cologne has an elegant spice to it, that almost demands it be worn by a man with a certain gravitas. Opium is seductive and always has worked well around women in my experience.

 

Overall Impressions of Opium Pour Homme

Opium Pour Homme is a fantastic fragrance for those who have the right style and sensibility. I don’t think it will mesh well with the stylistic presentation of some guys but I do know that it is a damn good smelling cologne.

I don’t have much left of my more vintage bottle and I’m pretty sure it got degraded from heat exposure, but I really do love this scent. Definitely more niche than many other colognes, but Opium EDT, just has a charm and essence that you don’t find too often.

Update: Since I did buy another bottle of EDT, I also bought a vintage bottle of Opium EDP. It is a deeper and better fragrance overall compared to this.

The vanilla, the spices, and the resinous quality are all great to experience. There aren’t too many mainstream designer releases that smell quite like Opium. The ginger and the star anise help to bring it all together for me.

Performance is good, not amazing, but I always felt as though I had gotten my money’s worth. It’s a cologne that seems to come and go from YSL’s collection, but for sure worth a try for those who want something different.