Polo Blue EDT vs EDP Cologne Comparison

Given my recent wear and review of Polo Blue EDP, I thought that I should do a comparison between that fragrance and the original Polo Blue EDT. While there is plenty of overlap between these two Ralph Lauren scents, the EDP does have a slightly different profile which gives it a distinction versus the Eau de Toilette. Which one smells better? Performs better? Is worth a purchase? Continue below for my thoughts.

Polo Blue EDT vs EDP: Which is Better?

Polo Blue Tale of the Tape

Notes include: amber, melon, patchouli, geranium, cucumber, tangerine, moss, musk

Click here to try: Polo Blue by Ralph Lauren for Men, Eau De Toilette Natural Spray, 4.2 Ounce

Read my original review: Polo Blue Review

Polo Blue EDP Tale of the Tape

Notes include: suede, bergamot, cardamom, basil, sea notes, sage, vetiver, woods

Click here to try: R.L. Polo Blue 4.2 oz / 125 ml Eau De Parfum EDP for Men

Read my original review: Polo Blue EDP Review

Opening

The original Polo Blue EDT is a fresh and crisp experience highlighted by the cucumber and melon notes. To me, that cologne always felt pretty bland, especially in the beginning of the wear.

You get those watery and crisp fruits with some light citrus. Then, the sage and basil ingredients, are seriously toned down when compared to the eau de parfum. I will say, it is fresh and I’ve grown to like it a bit more than I previously had, especially that hint of smooth suede.

Meanwhile, the EDP version strikes me as a blend of the EDT and Acqua Di Gio Profumo. The bergamot note leads off and gives it a citrus aroma to go along with the spice.

Eau de Parfum has much more character than the original and even if I’m not blown away by either, I prefer the EDP. It feels a little bit darker, more intense, and just more substantial.

Again, I’ve like Blue EDT more recently, than I had in the past. But, I’ll still go with the EDP for this category.

Edge: EDP

Projection

Both are moderate in how well they project. However, I will say that the EDP is a bit stronger than the original, but not by much. None of the scents from the Polo Blue lineup are powerhouses, with their sillage, and overall ability to project themselves in a room.

Edge: EDP

Longevity

Either one of these lasts in the 7-8 hour range usually. The EDP might have a slight advantage due to the strength of the bergamot note, but it’s basically even.

The line of Blue fragrances from Polo have all been pretty darn good on my skin. The Red’s have been more all over the map, but these seem to be pretty consistent across the board.

Edge: Push

Versatility

Both are casual and warmer weather scents. I actually think that the EDP has fit in quite well during these winter months, so I’ll give it the edge. Again, it’s not a huge difference.

Both colognes can be worn on a daily basis, but I think they feel more casual, than being office scents. You can wear them out, but they aren’t club bangers.

Edge: EDP

Overall

I think that the EDP is an improvement on the original. The initial similarities with Acqua Di Gio Profumo is a nice addition, as is the later enhanced suede and sea notes, that make the Eau de Parfum feel much more defined.

The original Polo Blue was a decent smelling and performing fragrance, I just found it pretty boring. The EDP on the other hand, has gained some points in its favor, and I actually quite like it.

Plus, I have found that I can usually buy a cheap bottle of Eternity Aqua, which is a near clone of the EDT version and get the same experience for less.

It’s still not my favorite scent but I have found myself wearing the sample a lot over the past few weeks and think that it’s a good buy for those who like citrus/aquatic/woodsy parfums.

Update: I would also put forward, the new release, Polo Deep Blue. It settles into something like a midpoint between the EDT and EDP, but with an interesting opening act of mango and marine notes.

Ranking the Blue releases, I’d have Deep Blue at number one. EDP at number 2. Gold Blend at 3. I have a bottle of Gold Blend, that I got for cheap, and I’d put it a notch below the other two.

If you want a more amber or aquatic fragrance, Deep Blue. If you want a spicier version of the original, EDP is the way to go.

Winner: Polo Blue EDP

Best Men's Colognes

Best Men’s Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with different fragrances, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, I have written hundreds of reviews and other pages about perfumes and colognes.