Ranking Y by YSL Fragrances

Y is one of the main and most popular lines for YSL currently. It’s getting closer to a decade since it’s initial release and there have now been plenty of iterations. But, which of them actually smell the best?

In this post, I am going to rank the Y colognes from my favorite to least favorite. I’ve linked my reviews for each of them, as well.

---

Best Y by YSL Scents Ranked

Note: I’m ranking everything here except for Y Live. I’m pretty sure that I’ve smelled that one, but I cannot recall it at all. So, rather than try to place this discontinued fragrance, I’m leaving it off.

---

Still the One

Y EDP– I still think the eau de parfum is the best one overall. Though, the apple and sage might be too intense for some people, and you might opt for Le Parfum or the EDT instead.

The EDP version takes the bergamot of the original and pairs it with a crisp apple note at the top. Meanwhile, you also get the cool spice of ginger, and the trio is quite captivating.

The apple is really great. Too often you can get weak or very unnatural smelling apple notes in men’s fragrances, but here, it becomes the star of the show. That top paired with the citrus and that familiar ginger aroma is just completely delicious.

The secondary layer under this main trio at the start is from amber, tonka bean, and a bit of juniper berry.

The performance is great. Y EDP lasts long and is also quite powerful. Y EDP review

---

The Parfum

Y Le Parfum– The opening act of Le Parfum is pretty similar in many ways to both Y EDP and EDT.

You get the apple and ginger combination up top, along with the sage and geranium already peaking through.

The difference is, Le Parfum isn’t nearly as bold, has more of a sweetness, while being greenish and somewhat dark. Yes, you do still get the citrus/fruity notes, it’s grapefruit here. Though, the addition of the aldehydes gives this one a bright/sweet/slightly fresh aroma.

Once I get past this initial phase, I really begin to enjoy Y Le Parfum. It becomes softer, with hints of sage still providing an edge, but with an attractive sweetness.

Apple, tonka bean, lavender, cedar, and geranium are running the show. A somewhat dark sweetness with a fresh woody base. It just doesn’t have the same density to my nose, as those others.

The final stage is lavender, tonka bean, and a mix of the remaining fruity and woody notes.

Apparently, they’ve significantly changed this formula for 2025. So, I’m talking about the original bottles here. Find one of those if you can. Though, I’m not sure how much of a difference there actually is. Y Le Parfum review

---

Higher Priced Concentration

Y Elixir– I think that the relative simplicity and pricing of Elixir caused this one to get somewhat of a negative reaction. But, on terms of how it smells, this is a very enjoyable and versatile cologne.

The geranium here is the one that is found in both EDP and Intense. But, a much more prominent role. Sometimes geranium can have a slight apple like smell to it, but I’m sure they just added a touch of the EDP mix to create a small hint of Y EDP’s opening act.

Nonetheless, that blue-ish tone is very much muted.

Lavender and geranium are the stars here, particularly the latter. The lavender gives this one a clean and soapy kind of aroma. But, that is more than offset by the spicy, earthy, crisp, woodsy freshness of the geranium.

Very cold and fresh in these early stages. Not as blue or bold as EDP for example. Though, this one has some depth and I enjoy how tame and easy to wear it is.

This is a very good option for a low key daily wear, that still has plenty of performance. Y Elixir review

---

The EDT

Y EDT– This is a very likeable fragrance. It’s a good one to get if you think that the EDP is too strong. This one is lighter and cleaner, great for daily wear. Plus, you can usually find a bottle for cheaper than others on the list.

It did get a slight revamp after its initial release. But, the ‘newer’ version has quite a lot of overlap with the original batches. YSL was pretty quick to change the formula, even slightly.

I think this might actually be some people’s favorite out of all of the options. It’s a great entry level cologne, not too challenging, but delivers plenty to enjoy. Y EDT review

---

Summer Fresh

Y Eau Fraiche– Eau Fraiche served as the summertime edition of the Y lineup. It wasn’t amazing by any stretch of the imagination. However, I thought it was a nice, if pretty simple fragrance.

Y Eau Fraiche kicks off with that immediately recognizable Y blend of notes. Here, you get overlap with the EDT from lemon, ginger, and mint in particular. Gone are the sage, pineapple, and apple. Very much cleaner and brighter than the original, but with a spicier bite.

There is a black pepper note, which joins that mint, and ginger. Cold and refreshing like a lemonade on a hot day.

As it moves along in the wear, the pepper and ginger fade away from my skin, and I get more geranium and cedar. Eau Fraiche starts smelling a bit more like the EDT, with less of the cold lemony punch, that started us off. Y Eau Fraiche review

---

Rounding things out

Y EDP Intense– I didn’t hate this one. I think that it’s an okay scent overall, but just not better than anything else on the list (maybe Eau Fraiche).

The opening of Y EDP Intense is pretty familiar, in terms of what you get with the rest of the series. The same blue-ish aroma is there early, along with the powerful sage note from Y Eau de parfum.

Intense doesn’t have the apple note, so, people who weren’t a fan of its sweetness may be pleased. It is replaced by a much shorter-lived juniper berry. I like its pairing here with the sage and other ingredients.

Early on you get a light bergamot, to go along with the cooler fresh spiciness. Geranium, ginger, and that sage note are all present creating a nice aromatic aroma.

I personally get around 20-30 minutes of this phase of the fragrance, before it begins to shift quite a bit. Things get earthier, warmer, less spicy.

After that, it’s kind of boring. Nothing too unique, but this one has a heavier patchouli and vetiver with the lavender note also hanging around. It’s always just been mid to me. Y EDP Intense review