Y Elixir vs Y EDP by YSL

YSL keeps churning out flankers of the Y formula, which are all generally pretty good at least. Y Elixir is the release for the line in 2024. Meanwhile, Y eau de parfum has been the most popular edition for years now.

In this post, I want to compare and contrast each of these scents, and break down which is better by different metrics. Which smells best? Lasts longer? Is the better buy?

---

Tale of the Tape: Y Eau de Parfum vs. Elixir

Notes include: bergamot, apple, ginger, sage, vetiver, geranium, juniper berries, tonka bean, amber, cedar

Click here to try: Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum Spray for Men, 3.3 Ounce

Read my review: Y EDP

---

Y Elixir

Notes include: lavender, geranium, oud, incense

---

Opening

Y EDP starts off with its bold kick. It’s a strong bergamot, apple, and ginger blend initially. Then, will come the amber, juniper berry, and tonka bean.

Though, that initial burst is quite juicy, bold, and blue.

Some people don’t seem to care for the opening act. I actually think that its that amber and juniper layer that can put some people who’ve tried EDP off. But for me, the apple and bergamot pairing really grabs my attention with its crisp bite.

The sage also comes through quite a bit, even at this early point of the process.

With, Y Elixir we are going to get something that is seemingly familiar, but goes in another direction. You will catch aspects of Y EDP in Elixir, no citrus, but there seems to be some of the apple still around (may just be the geranium).

Lavender and geranium are the stars here, especially the second one. The lavender gives this one a clean and soapy kind of aroma. But, that is more than offset by the spicy, earthy, crisp, woodsy freshness of the geranium.

Very cold and fresh in these early stages. Not as blue or bold as EDP for example. Though, this one has some depth and I enjoy how tame and easy to wear it is.

Oud adds to the base and the woodiness. However, it just isn’t all that massive of a note here in the early stages. Also, an incense note provides a smokiness which also isn’t too pervasive. Both are really nice in the support of the other two notes.

Which is better? I usually prefer eau de parfum to others in this series. Though, I think Y Elixir takes this opening act for me. It’s mellow, fresh, woodsy, and well put together.

Edge: Elixir

---

Projection

Y EDP is very strong at the start. I can spray my bottle and fill the room with its scent, with not too many sprays.

The first 30-60 minutes are powerful. After that, it’s strong before settling into something that is above average. Y EDP doesn’t radiate that scent like crazy the whole way through.

Elixir is no slouch. It just doesn’t hit the same high level that the eau de parfum does. It’s also slightly above average for most of the wear, but it also projects very well for that first hour or so.

Just not to the same degree.

Edge: EDP

---

Longevity

Y eau de parfum lasts for about 10 hours on my skin. For me, it’s still the best performing fragrance in this YSL series.

Y Elixir actually sticks around well. Falls a bit short of the EDP, but it’s better than Le Parfum, in this regard.

I get close to 9 hours of longevity out of Elixir. Quite good, not elite, and not as long-lasting as Y EDP.

Edge: EDP

---

Versatility

Y EDP and Elixir are both good, nearly year round. I might prefer Elixir in the hotter weather, but it’s not exactly built for that either.

Y Elixir without the bold citrus and apple notes, comes across as being a bit more mature and professional.

Elixir is a super versatile fragrance. It can do everything that Y EDP can do; plus, it can be an office wear, or something you spray on for a low key evening out. It’s attractive enough to catch attention, without being overwhelming.

Edge: Elixir

---

Overall Scent

Overall, this was a lot closer than I expected it to be prior to testing out Y Elixir.

Elixir is a really nice fragrance. As of now, it’s right up there with Le Parfum, tied for my second favorite Y cologne. I’m not sure which of them gets the nod, possibly Elixir, since it has better performance.

The opening act is really fantastic. It’s got just enough spice, some incense/oud smokiness, and really let’s that geranium note shine. I’m a big fan of geranium.

The back half is still quite good, more lavender and geranium, with a woodsy undertone. The aroma itself is quite a bit like Y EDP at this point, just less dynamic and interesting.

I’m still choosing Y EDP. It’s better for the entirety of the wear and has a stronger performance. Though, Elixir was close to making this a coin toss, I just prefer EDP more.

Y Elixir is a very versatile scent and might be the one you would want to go with as a daily office wear or something along those lines.

Elixir at the higher price point, might feel too ‘run of the mill’ for some who want a bolder sort of fragrance. I really enjoy Elixir, but Y EDP is still probably a better bet for most people.

Winner: Y EDP