As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on an Amazon affiliate link on my pages, I receive a commission based on that qualified purchase. It doesn't cost you any more money and it helps keep the site running.
YSL currently has multiple releases in its men’s fragrance catalog, that have achieved a great deal of popularity. Y eau de parfum is a best seller and has been for more than a handful of years now.
Myslf EDP is a more recent release, but has also become a favorite among fragrance enjoyers, and will no doubt spawn further perfumes under the Myslf title. However, which of these two colognes is better? Which lasts longer? Which is the better buy?
Tale of the Tape: Myslf vs. Y EDP
Myslf
Notes include: bergamot, orange blossom, woods, patchouli, ambrofix
Click here to try: Myslf by YSL
My Full Review: Myslf
Y Eau de Parfum
Notes include: bergamot, apple, ginger, sage, vetiver, geranium, juniper berries, tonka bean, amber, cedar
Click here to try: Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau de Parfum Spray for Men, 3.3 Ounce
Read my review: Y EDP
Opening
Y EDP starts off with its bold kick. It’s a strong bergamot, apple, and ginger blend initially. Then, will come the amber, juniper berry, and tonka bean. However, that initial blast is quite juicy, bold, and blue.
I know some people don’t like that initial punch, but I love it. I actually think that its that amber and juniper layer that can put some folks off. But for me, the apple and bergamot pairing really grabs my attention with its crisp bite.
The sage also comes through quite a bit, even at this early point of the process.
Myslf starts off with bergamot and orange blossom, as it’s main two ingredients. It’s fresh, dynamic, and it also has a bit of a creaminess to the aroma. The orange blossom adds that aspect, but doesn’t get to add too much sweetness during the beginning.
But, the very opening stage is a bergamot centered fragrance. That will change later on, but for the start it’s a fresh citrusy cologne.
Which is better? This is a close race between them, as sometimes Y EDP can be a bit too bold for me in the opening act. Yet, I think that I still prefer what I get versus Myslf, at the start. Both are enjoyable, but I have a slight preference.
Edge: Y EDP
Projection
Y EDP does start off with plenty of punch and it comes across as being quite strong. However, I’d call it above average overall. Not a monster, but very solid and noticeable throughout.
That first hour or so, can be a lot, especially when going with a higher number of sprays. Though, it always seems to calm down for me, while still having a good amount strength.
Myslf for the first hour is actually pretty strong. Not a heavy fragrance, but it will create a substantial enough scent trail in your wake. It never hits the same level as the other YSL scent.
After that, it’s more of an intimate scent surrounding you. I’d say it sticks in that 1-3 foot range off of the skin, but it’s still noticeable.
An easy win for Y.
Edge: Y EDP
Longevity
Y EDP lasts for about 10 hours on my skin. It might go for a little longer or even for a shorter duration, depending on the circumstances. However, it almost always seems to hit that double digit mark for me.
Myslf EDP lasts for 6-7 hours, before it has faded away entirely. It’s fine, just not a great performer. Especially, in comparison to my bottle of Y.
Y eau de parfum is much more of a performer than what you’ll get with the serviceable, newer YSL release.
Edge: Y EDP
Versatility
Myslf eau de parfum is an easy to wear fragrance, that it can fit in pretty much anywhere during any time of year. Maybe not during the daytime in summer, but outside of that it’s fine.
It’s an easy on to just spray on as an everyday wear, but is attractive enough to hit the nightlife, even if that’s not it’s main function. It’s not going to overwhelm and can work for all age groups without issue.
Y EDP will also work pretty much year round. Again, I’d go with something lighter on the hottest days of the year.
It is also one that can fit in basically anywhere. Neither of these is the most formal fragrance ever and you might want to go with Myslf, if you want a scent that is more understated. However, I don’t see much separation in this category.
Edge: Push
Overall Scent
Myslf EDP is an enjoyable wear. Simple and pleasant. I like the opening act with the citrus burst, it’s very versatile, and can easily slot in as a daily wear cologne.
There’s some additional woodiness and amber, in the back half. Though, this fragrance isn’t too complicated. The performance is decent, but not great, and I don’t think the scent overall holds up in comparison to Y.
Y EDP smells great and has mass appeal. Sometimes, I’m not in the mood for such a blue-ish cologne, but this YSL works perfectly when I am.
It has similarities with other popular fragrances, but utilizes different notes, to make it distinct from the pack. I love the apple, bergamot, and sage at the top. The crispness, the clean and modern scent, and the performance doesn’t disappoint.
For me, I enjoy the experience of wearing Y more so than what I get with Myslf. Even if, I think that the latter one is a very nice perfume. I would still choose Y EDP over the other release, Myslf Le Parfum, also.
Winner: Y EDP
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
User Review
( votes)
Best Men’s Colognes started back in 2013, as a way to share my learning experiences with the different fragrances that I’ve owned, as I dove head first into the hobby. Since then, that new hobby grew into a consistent passion, helping millions of readers along the way. I have personally written reviews for well over 800 perfumes and colognes for both men and women. This is along with writing hundreds of other in-depth fragrance guides.