Carlisle by Parfums de Marly

For this entry into my long running review posts, we have a cologne from Parfums de Marly, Carlisle. This one was released in 2015 and there’s been a lot of hype behind it, but is it actually any good? What are the ingredients? How does it smell? In this post, I want to break down my thoughts and experiences wearing this fragrance, and if I think this scent is a winner.

---

What does Carlisle Smell Like?

Notes include: vanilla, sandalwood, patchouli, nutmeg, saffron, tonka bean, apple

Click here to try: Carlisle by Parfums de Marly

---

My Full Wear Review

Before we dive into my review, let’s see what Parfums de Marly has to say about Carlisle: This voluptuous fragrance is structured around one main accord ‘sandalwood’. Warm, sweet like a balm, it leaves a trail with of vanilla & dark patchouli. This composition takes heart in distilling a mysterious “oriental” aura, playing with its delicate accents of nutmeg, saffron, and tonka bean. It is the unexpected union between the crisp of a green apple and the softness of vanilla, yet with a rich and textured arrangement revealing itself on the skin like a captivating smile. 

The opening of Carlisle immediately brings to mind other Parfums de Marly fragrances, mainly Oajan, but this one strikes me as being better at times. Other times, I’d say they’re even. I have a full bottle of Oajan, so, that’s a nice surprise.

It opens up with that crisp green apple note, saffron, vanilla, and sandalwood. It is very warm, sweet, with a non-harsh spice; has that gourmand sort of baked goods aroma but darker. Carlisle is a rich cologne with depth and an interesting life cycle.

Saffron really sticks out to my nose here and it plays off of the other notes to create a leathery type of smell. Now, I haven’t found leather as an ingredient in any of the note listings online, so I’m assuming its just an illusion of sorts.

Either way, it smells great, and lends a definite smoothness the the composition with the vanilla and tonka bean.

As it dries down further, I get less of the apple sweetness, and more patchouli and smokiness. It’s not a super heavy patchouli, which is nice, and it does have a ‘balmy’ feeling like Parfums de Marly was describing.

Nutmeg definitely lets itself be known, when I put my nose directly to my skin, and pairs well with the vanilla.

Ultimately, what I get out of the cologne is: sandalwood as the starting point, vanilla, patchouli, saffron, and tonka bean. Everything else, turns into a bit player.

It’s a perfect blend between sweet and warm spice. Not basic candy sweet, but well blended, and totally refined. Carlisle is dark throughout with a light touch of smokiness.

---

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Projection wise, Carlisle is strong, but not offensively so. You could over spray it, but with any normal amount, that won’t be a problem. It sticks to the skin well and the sillage is consistent throughout.

With this scent, I get all day wear from it without a problem. This is one of those colognes that will touch double digits, in terms of hours. I’d say that it ultimately falls in the 12 or 13 hour range. Really pretty much all you need for any effective use.

Seasonally, it will mostly be great for cold weather. However, I think that it should hold up nicely in moderate to warm temperatures, as well. Just not into extreme heat or humidity situations.

Carlisle also has very good versatility with what situations you could wear it in. It’s more of a dressed up kind of fragrance, it works in the office, romantically, late nights out, suited up, etc.

It does have a wonderful smell that is seductive and sexy. Folks around the wearer should take a liking to this scent.

---

Overall Impressions of Carlisle

Overall, do I like Carlisle? Yes, I think that it is great. This is one of the best men’s fragrances by Parfums de Marly and a nice all around wear. It is familiar to me, by being related to other colognes from this brand, but still has its own identity.

The sandalwood and saffron really got my attention and my positive feelings were only solidified with the vanilla, apple, and nutmeg. I’ve enjoyed wearing this scent. If you’re not into warm, sweet, smoky colognes…this isn’t for you, though.

But, I think that this will have a mass appeal, and many guys would enjoy wearing this. the only question is the price point, which is outside of the realm of possibility for many.