Fragrances

Versace Eros vs Eau Fraiche Cologne Comparison

by

Versace has a whole line of wonderful smelling men’s colognes and two of the best selling fragrances in the world belong to the franchise, Eros and Versace Man Eau Fraiche. As such, many guys narrow their choice of what cologne to purchase to between these Versace gems.

How do they compare? Which one smells better? Which lasts longer? In this post, I want to compare these two scents and try to determine a clear winner or at least point to some deciding factors, that should help make a decision.

Tale of the Tape: Eau Fraiche vs. Eros

Versace Eros

Notes of Eros: mint, green apple, tonka bean, madagascar vanilla, vetiver

Read my Eros review

Shop Amazon for: Versace Eros Eau de Toilette Spray for Men, 3.4 Fluid Ounce

Versace Man Eau Fraiche 

Notes include: Lemon, Rosewood, Carambola, Cedar leaves, Tarragon, Sage, Musk, Amber, Sycamore

My original review

Click here to try: Versace Man Eau Fraiche By Gianni Versace For Men Edt Spray 3.4 Oz

Opening

The opening of Eros is rich and complex. It’s a gourmand type of scent that blends the crispness of mint and apple with the smooth flavors of tonka bean and vanilla.

Update: Newer bottles seem to have more lemon, then they used to. As such, the opening act has a more noticeable citrus kick.

Eau Fraiche is a very cool fragrance that opens with the scent of frozen citrus, you literally get a chilled scent. It’s quite sharp with lemon and starfruit. Add to that, some rosemary spice and the freshness of the woody base.

I think Eros has more character and is more interesting from the beginning, though I have no complaints about either. I do really like the starfruit aspect of Eau Fraiche, but I’d still give Eros the edge.

Update: Ehhh, coming back to these two. I am going to change it to Fraiche. Maybe it’s just me, but the balance of the newer Eros bottles seems off. The opening of Fraiche is sharp and fresh, but strikes me as a bit better now.

Edge: Fraiche

Projection

Neither of these bad boys is weak by any means. Eros is loud and heavy. Seriously, I wouldn’t ever overdo this scent. Eau Fraiche is no slouch and while not as strong as Eros it can still be a projection beast, at first.

Update: Eros has weakened somewhat, but is still ahead in this matchup. Eau Fraiche becomes more of a moderate, the further along you get into it. It’s sharpness up top, does project very well, though.

Edge: Eros

Longevity

Again, both are good performers. All day wear from both. Eros just doesn’t seem to quit sometimes, while Man Eau Fraiche, usually gets me 6-7 hours of solid wear before tapering off.

Update: Nowadays, I get in the 8-9 hour range with Eros. Not double digits anymore.

Edge: Eros

Versatility

To me, this is where the true decision lies between these two colognes. Eros is a cold weather fragrance and can be too much for casual situations (at least use it lightly).

Meanwhile, Eau Fraiche is a classic summetime scent, it can hold up during the rest of the year but it has that warm weather vibe to it. Plus, Eau Fraiche, is better for casual situations since it is not as heavy.

Eau Fraiche just has an easier time fitting in during a greater number of scenarios. Neither is a formal fragrance, however.

Edge: Eau Fraiche

Overall Scent

I like Eros better. I just find the warmth and complexity inherently appealing. However, Versace Man Eau Fraiche is probably more serviceable as an everyday wear. One is built for the winter while another shines in the summer.

They really are on two ends of the spectrum, so the best buy is up to your personal needs from the fragrance. I’d rather wear Eros out of these two. Even, with the slight changes I pick up from newer bottles of Eros, I still would gravitate toward that more often.

That being said, it’s much closer than it used to be and I’m very close to give Fraiche the win straight up. If I’m going to get a lemony opening from both, I like the pairing with starfruit from Fraiche.

The mint, vanilla, lemon blend used to be better. But, on the whole, Eros still has plenty going for it.

Winner: Eros (very slightly)

Versace Eros vs Invictus Cologne Comparison

by

It’s been a little bit since I’ve done a cologne comparison on the site and I really don’t know how I haven’t weighed in on today’s two competitors, head to head: Versace Eros vs Invictus by Paco Rabanne. These are two of the most popular fragrances out on the market today, especially with younger men.

In this post, I will cover which one smells better, performs better, has more versatility, and which is the best buy. I have linked my original reviews of each cologne below, so check those out too.

Tale of the Tape: Invictus vs. Eros

Versace Eros

Notes of Eros: mint, green apple, tonka bean, madagascar vanilla, vetiver, Italian lemon

Click here to try: Versace Eros Men Eau De Toilette Spray, 6.7 Fluid Ounce

My original Versace Eros Review

Invictus

Notes include: grapefruit, sea notes, mandarin orange, bay leaf, jasmine

Read my review

Click here to try: Paco Rabanne Invictus Eau de Toilette Spray for Men, 3.4 Ounce

Opening

Invictus has a very nice and youthful citrus opening that is highly sweet and pretty candy-like in its aroma. Less of a natural juicy fruit and more of synthetic candied one.

This is paired with sea notes to give this Paco Rabanne fragrance, a summery and marine vibe. It’s all quite upbeat and sunny. The grapefruit and mandarin here are synthetic, but the aroma has grown on me over time.

Meanwhile, Eros is loud and bold, right from the start. Invictus can be that way too, but the Versace can be really strong.

Italian lemon is joined by green apple and a crisp and cool mint note. This is the intense period before Eros fully develops its masculine warmth and envelopes the wearer. In newer bottles of Eros, I get way more of the lemon note than I did with original batches.

Between the two, I like how Eros opens a bit more. Invictus is quite nice, but I like the mint note in Eros better than what its competitor can offer. Eros doesn’t seem as good to me as it used to, but I think it still takes this head to head.

Edge: Eros

Projection

Invictus really does put up a fight. It is a good clubbing scent and has quite a big opening hour or so. However, I don’t think it ever matches Eros in its level of projection, and certainly doesn’t maintain the sillage throughout. Invictus moves more towards a moderate after an hour or so, while Eros stays beasty for much longer.

Update: Newer bottles of Eros, still seem to have better sillage than Invictus, it’s just not a complete monster anymore.

Edge: Eros

Longevity

Again, not only does Invictus fail to match the sillage output, and falls to a moderate in short order. Invictus also doesn’t last as long as Eros. I will say that, Invictus is quite solid, and actually lasts long enough for most all purposes or occasions. I’ve always gotten 6-7 hours from it on my skin.

Versace Eros, gets me 10 hours pretty easily. Do you always need that much? No, but it can do it.

Update: The last batch of Eros that I tried was around 7-8 hours. Still better than what I get from Invictus, just not nearly as much of a discrepancy. Eros used to be complete beast mode, but it gets the job done nowadays too.

Edge: Eros

Versatility

Both of these scents trend towards the younger set. Think teens through mid-20s. Not to say, an older guy couldn’t wear it, but that’s most of the age range. I do actually feel that this is one category, in which Invictus takes the edge.

Because it calms down and isn’t as loud, it can be worn in close quarters without dominating the room. Eros can do that sort of, as long as one doesn’t spray more than two times max.

Also, I think Invictus performs well in many different climates, while Eros is more of a cold weather scent. Both are great for the nightlife. Though, Invictus just seems to check more boxes in this category.

Edge: Invictus

Overall Scent

Without a doubt, I’m going to give the nod to Eros. The Versace is just the better scent all around for me. It has so much more depth and character. Both are sweet colognes, but Eros has further woods and vetiver, that makes it more interesting to me.

I actually do like Invictus, though, not nearly my favorite scent. It is super sweet and has an attractive profile, but doesn’t touch Eros’ level, in my opinion. The opening is the highlight of Invictus, but even then I still prefer Eros.

Invictus is a very nice choice for younger guys and women around that age seem to enjoy it. It has a nice aquatic vibe with the citrus notes, that is simply upbeat and fun to wear. But push come to shove, I’m riding with Eros almost every time.

If you need one of them to be more of an all-around wear, in warmer climates, then it can make sense to go with Invictus instead.

Winner: Versace Eros

YSL Y vs L’Homme by YSL Cologne Comparison

by

For this edition of the head to head fragrance match ups, we have two selections from Yves Saint Laurent’s men’s line, Y EDT vs. L’Homme EDT. Which of these colognes smells the best? The ever popular L’Homme or the more recent release from YSL? Which gives a better performance? Has more versatility? Is the better buy overall?

Tale of the Tape: L’Homme vs. Y EDT

Y EDT

Notes include: bergamot, ginger, aldehydes, violet leaf, geranium, sage, cedar, musk, incense, ambergris, fir

Click here to try: Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau De Toilette Spray 100ml/3.3oz

Review: Y EDT

L’Homme

Notes include: Virginia Cedar, Ginger, Violet, Citron, White Pepper, Basil Flower, Ozone, Tonka Bean, Sandalwood, Vetiver

Click here to try: L’homme By Yves Saint Laurent Eau De Toilette Spray For Men 3.3 oz

Review: L’Homme by YSL

Opening

Y Eau de toilette, opens with a super clean, crisp, and cool aroma that is led by bergamot and aldehydes. The bergamot is light and gives that juicy citrus aroma, while the aldehydes act as a clean ray of sunshine, to brighten up the composition further.

Plus, an herbal/minty coolness. After that, you get ginger with violet leaf, and a warm ambergris.

L’Homme also has the bergamot opening but it is light and more well-blended with the surrounding notes than is Y.

The bergamot is paired with ginger and basil for a dash of spice and a creamy tonka bean note to help create a smoothly clean effect. Much like Y, there is an additional violet leaf note, that pops up.

That bergamot and ginger pairing is simply awesome together. There are lighter peppery spices in the mix, but it’s not overwhelming.

Which is better? These two fragrances do share plenty of overlap between them. However, I think the L’Homme smells better at the start of the wear.

I’ve always really enjoyed that aspect of this YSL cologne. Y isn’t bad, but it just doesn’t have the same blend of spice and sweetness that L’Homme achieves.

Edge: L’Homme

Projection

Y and L’Homme are both light fragrances. Neither has very much sillage. They both can start out fairly moderate but will quickly move into becoming skin scents whenever I wear them. No real edge in this one.

Update: Y EDT is more consistent with its projection and probably has better sillage than newer bottles of L’homme. So, I’m changing it.

Edge: Y EDT

Longevity

My biggest problem with YSL’s L’Homme was always the longevity. On my skin, I can only get it to last for 4-5 hours, and then its basically gone.

Y EDT isn’t much better, but it is slightly, clocking in at close to 7 hours. It’s like 6-7 hours almost every time, but not beyond that.

Update: Newer bottles of L’Homme are even worse. Y EDT is now much better than L’Homme.

Edge: Y 

Versatility

Both of these fragrances shine for moderate to warm weather in the springtime to early summer. However, they are kind of year round colognes, which aren’t unusable in any conditions really (outside of extreme heat and humidity, perhaps).

They are both used as casual or office wear scents, but not really ideal for the nightlife. They fill the same role, no clear winner.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

This is a tough comparison to do, because there isn’t a choice that is head and shoulders above the other. Y EDT is a very nice and light scent that is quite pleasant in its simplicity.

It has a balanced composition, smells really good, but isn’t all that interesting. It’s safe, but won’t really turn heads.

L’Homme, is the better smelling cologne of the two, even if it has worse longevity. I’ve always enjoyed the scent and wished that it was stronger, as the release of L’Homme Intense was quite different from the original, and not simply a beefed up version.

The performance of both leaves much to be desired. Both have similar strengths, yet Y lasts a tad longer as mostly a skin scent. L’Homme smells the best. I’m going to give the nod to L’Homme, even with its weaknesses, because I find it to be a better composition. It’s a very slight winner.

Frankly, I prefer Y EDP (Review) to either of these, as it smells better than EDT and has great performance.

Update: While L’homme smells better still. It’s performance is pretty terrible nowadays. As such, I’d go with Y EDT now out of these two. Y is a nice fragrance and some decent performance.

Winner: Y EDT

Prada Luna Rossa Sport vs Carbon Comparison

by

In this edition of this site’s head to head cologne comparisons, we have a battle between two Prada Luna Rossa flanker fragrances: Sport vs. Carbon. Both of these scents have been praised and enjoyed popularity, but which one smells better? Has greater performance? Versatility? Finally, which one is more of a joy to wear? Please continue below for my full take on these Prada colognes.

Tale of the Tape: Sport vs. Carbon

Luna Rossa Carbon

Notes include: lavender, ambroxan, metallic notes, pepper, patchouli, coal, bergamot

Click here to try: Prada Luna Rossa CARBON for Men Eau de Toilette Spray, 3.4 ounce

Luna Rossa Sport

Notes include: vanilla, lavender, tonka bean, juniper berries, ginger

Click here to try: Prada Luna Rossa SPORT Eau de Toilette Spray 3.4 oz

Opening

Luna Rossa Carbon opens with a blend of lavender, ambroxan, bergamot, and pepper. Bergamot acts as the main top note and it all can come off, as another version of Dior Sauvage to many people.

However, the lavender note is heavier in Carbon than in the Dior. It feels smoother and cleaner in its opening act versus Sauvage EDT. Less spicy with a touch of citrus from that bergamot.

Sport, hits you with tonka bean, lavender, and vanilla. It doesn’t have that same bright citrus element as Carbon, nor does it share the metallic notes.

Beyond that, you get a slight ginger spice and the aromatic freshness of juniper. It’s a bit sweet early on, with enough spice to go with the cleaner elements of the fragrance.

Lavender is the shared DNA between these two colognes. I prefer the smooth and crisp clean feeling of Luna Rossa Sport over that sharp bergamot citrus blend found in Carbon.

Edge: Sport

Projection

Carbon starts off loud but then fades more to the upper end of moderate on the spectrum. Sillage wise, Sport is pretty moderate throughout and doesn’t hit the levels of projection that Carbon does.

Neither is an absolute powerhouse. Also, Sport isn’t weak. Carbon just takes this category with issue. Carbon just has a higher ceiling and greater consistency during the wear, than does Luna Rossa Sport.

Edge: Carbon

Longevity

When I wear Carbon, it can hit double digits in how many hours, it lasts on my skin. 10+ is pretty normal for this cologne, sometimes it may go less than that.

While Sport, is no slouch, is seems to only muster around 6-7 hours. It’s fine, just not something that’s going to last all day.

So, obviously, Carbon has the edge in this performance category. Sport just isn’t a beast and can’t match the levels of strength that Carbon can. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, depending on your own needs.

Edge: Carbon

Versatility

Both of these fragrances are highly versatile. That’s a part of the strength of each. It doesn’t matter if it’s casually, at the office, or on a date. The main differences come during the summer months and which one gets more complements.

Luna Rossa Carbon does a better job at holding up in the humidity of summer. Meanwhile, I like wearing Sport for dates or during evening outs, as women seem to notice it more. There doesn’t appear to be a clear cut winner in terms of versatility.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

I like Luna Rossa Carbon. It’s nice, it has that Sauvage appeal, but is distinct when you get close and notice the details. It also performs extremely well and does everything you could ask it to.

BUT…I simply like wearing Sport more. It’s a very simple kind of cologne, but it’s damn good within that simplicity. The tonka bean goes perfectly with that signature Luna Rossa lavender and the vanilla flanking it.

Also, the ginger and barely noticeable juniper give it an extra undertone that I really enjoy. It’s crisp and has enough spice to grab attention. It’s in that same sort of mold as Code Profumo, which I also adore.

So, yes, Carbon has better performance and if you want something with more of a citrus profile, give it a look. The lavender clean and the metallic aroma during the dry down is actually pretty enjoyable. It’s still one of the better Luna Rossa releases.

However, I’m going to pick Luna Rossa Sport, as it is the better smelling Prada cologne in my mind.

Winner: Luna Rossa Sport

Venetian Bergamot by Tom Ford

by

Continuing through my review of a whole lot of Tom Ford fragrances, we have a 2015 release, entitled: Venetian Bergamot. I want to take a closer look at this fragrance after I’ve been testing it out for a while. How does it smell? What are the notes? How does it perform? Is it worth a purchase?

What does Venetian Bergamot Smell Like?

Notes include: bergamot, pink pepper, black pepper, amber, sandalwood, tonka bean, ylang ylang, ginger, magnolia, gardenia, cedar

Click here to try: TOM Ford Private Blend Venetian Bergamot EDP Spray 3.4 Oz / 100 Ml Sealed

My Full Wear Review

The opening of Venetian Bergamot obviously features that familiar citrus bergamot opening, but this one definitely doesn’t take the familiar route with it. Not only is there a spice to the aroma, there are also floral notes, which create something that is quite unique.

However, even with the other elements being involved from the jump, it is still mostly the juicy and somewhat sour citrus smell with sandalwood peaking through. The start is much more of a tropical scent than what you get during the rest of the wear and I find it really enjoyable.

As it dries down further, Venetian Bergamot, becomes less of a bergamot scent and the floral notes being to take over the composition.

This is mainly gardenia with some ylang ylang. So, at this point it is the floral notes, pink and black pepper, sandalwood, and a fading bergamot. It is smooth and creamy with bright elements that really perk up the senses.

I think that the most interesting aspect of this Tom Ford fragrance is the spicy notes in here. They aren’t heavy spices however, the white ginger is a nice addition to the warm pink pepper, and the hint of sharp black pepper sprinkled throughout.

This is what keeps the fragrance in the unisex category, even as the white floral notes pull it toward the feminine side of things.

What I ultimately get from Venetian Bergamot when all is said and done is, a gardenia/ylang ylang combo sitting on top of sandalwood and cedar, with a mix of bergamot and spices floating around this core composition.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Projection wise it’ll be in the 3-6 foot range. The sillage of this one is pretty moderate, and works down into something light and close to the skin. So, the first 3-4 hours, it will be a moderate scent. Then for the rest of the time, VB is much more of a skin scent.

It does last in the 7-8 hour range on my skin, so the longevity ain’t too shabby. For a lot of that wear, it’ll be the woods with some light floral touches. The bergamot doesn’t completely last all that time, but the blend is fairly creamy and has a clean soapy quality.

Seasonally, Venetian Bergamot is one for the spring and summer months. Between the citrus and floral notes, it begs to be worn in the warm weather. As I said, it is unisex that leans more towards the feminine side of things, but this is still completely safe to wear for men.

It’s classy and has an expensive air about it. Not really a sexy fragrance but one that smells nice and can be worn in dressy casual or more upscale scenarios. It is completely office safe.

This one is better worn when dressed up or for at least more semi-formal occasions during the spring and summer.

Overall Impressions of Venetian Bergamot

Overall, do I like Venetian Bergamot? I do like it. It is a bit too floral for my taste and I wish it stayed closer to what it is at the opening, rather than, drying down to gardenia, ylang ylang, and magnolia.

That being said, it is still a very nice perfume, that has a unique scent and decent performance.

I do like the bergamot, ginger, and spiciness of that opening. With the name, I was expecting to get more of a pure bergamot, but it ends up with a greater use of the gardenia. That’s fine, just not what I was expecting when I first tried Venetian Bergamot.

It’s by no means a beast in terms of its performance, so at this price point it might be a pass. Though, it isn’t entirely terrible either. Value is okay, but that’s your call.

However, if you’re looking for a citrus or floral fragrance and want to try something different, Venetian Bergamot is worthy of consideration. It’s not one of the top tier Tom Ford perfumes, but it’s in the upper half or even third, for sure.