Armaf Club de Nuit Intense vs. Aventus

by

Creed’s Aventus has been so mega-popular over the past decade, it has created its own sub-industry of fragrances trying to mimic or outright match its appealing formula.

The most popular of these fragrances is Armaf’s Club de Nuit Intense EDP. But, how do these two scents actually compare? Does Club smell better? Last longer?

Quick Overview

My Verdict

Creed Aventus is the better fragrance overall. It has better balance, higher quality, more depth, and slightly better longevity.

Club de Nuit Intense EDP is still a great alternative because it gives you much of the Aventus style for far less money.

If price is not a concern, Aventus wins. If value matters most, Club de Nuit Intense EDP makes a lot of sense. Here’s another inexpensive alternative from the Dua Brand that’s very similar: Poseidon’s Elixir

Category Armaf Club de Nuit Intense EDP Creed Aventus Winner
Opening Fruitier than Aventus, with more apple and less smokiness early on. The birch is less leathery until later in the wear. Pineapple, blackcurrant, citrus, birch, oak moss, apple, and vanilla. Better balanced and more engaging from the start. Creed Aventus
Projection Projects strongly and stays above average throughout the wear. Also projects strongly, with no major difference in reach compared with Club de Nuit Intense EDP. Tie
Longevity Lasts around 7-9 hours, though it tends to sit closer to the lower end of that range. Lasts around 7-10 hours, usually landing closer to 8-9 hours with better consistency. Creed Aventus
Versatility Works as an all-season fragrance, dressed up or casual, though it is better outside of extreme heat. Covers the same ground as Club de Nuit Intense EDP and works dressed up, casual, and across most seasons. Tie
Overall Scent A very good Aventus-style scent for the money, but it misses some of the depth, quality, and small details of the Creed. Better quality, greater depth, more balance, and slightly better performance. Still the better fragrance by smell. Creed Aventus

Tale of the Tape: Club de Nuit Intense vs. Aventus

Creed Aventus 

creed aventus

Notes of Creed Aventus: 

Top: Blackcurrant, Italian bergamot, French apples and pineapple

Middle: Rose, dry birch, Moroccan jasmine, and patchouli

Base Notes: musk, oak moss, ambergris, and vanilla.

Click here to read my original Aventus Review

Click here to get Aventus: Aventus by Creed

Club de Nuit EDP

Notes include: lemon, apple, blackcurrant, birch, jasmine, rose, vanilla, musk, ambergris, patchouli

Click here to try: Club de Nuit Men EDP

Opening

The sharp pineapple note, with the other citrus and woodsy elements of Aventus has never been something I enjoyed all that much.

That opening isn’t a favorite of mine, but Armaf is the same as well, so no luck in getting something different for me.

The pineapple, blackcurrant, and the dryness of birch can be a bit much at first. However, I do like what it settles into.

Fresh and lively, very enjoyable to wear. Next, you get less pineapple, and more of the birch wood and oak moss. This is where Aventus comes into its own. Plus, a little vanilla sweetness and the remaining apple note.

With Club EDP, I find it to be a smoother version of the EDT from Armaf. I get more of the apple note too, from this version.

The differences here are that Club has a fruitier start. Less smokiness and the birch wood doesn’t have the leathery facets, until later on in the wear. At least on my skin.

Which is better? While I don’t personally enjoy either’s opening act all that much. The Creed quality is higher and I do like the birch wood note better in the original.

Obviously, these two are going to be quite similar, but Aventus still has a nicer balance of its notes and a more engaging scent from the get go.

Edge: Aventus

Projection

Both of these fragrances start off with a good deal of strength and project quite well off of the skin. For the duration of the wear, they are both above average, in this regard.

I’m not sure that Aventus is actually any stronger than Club de Nuit Intense. There may be a slight difference here, but I’m not really getting it.

I’ve tested both of them on skin and have applied to clothing. Putting each fragrance onto a shirt and placing it on a chair, I can detect either of them from about the same distance, when I’ve done this.

No massive difference here.

Edge: Push

Longevity

Club will last for 7-9 hours, on my skin. The more I try it, the more it seems to settle closer to the bottom of that range. Still, very good.

Aventus is a 7-10 hour fragrance. Overlapping with the Armaf. However, I usually get 8-9 hours from the Creed version. It has a higher ceiling and more consistency.

Club de Nuit Intense EDP does give you plenty of wear for the money. That’s why it’s one of, if not the most popular of the Aventus-like colognes out there. Armaf didn’t dilute the idea with a bad performing scent, yet it still is a step behind.

Edge: Aventus

Versatility

There’s no distinction here. One’s mimicking the other, so they cover the same ground.

Mostly all-season fragrances that can be worn dressed up or even more casually. I’d avoid the hottest days of the year with either and both are better in the autumn and early spring, in my opinion.

Really great at being ‘jack of all trades’ sort of fragrances. But, this category is a tie.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

Between these two, I do still think that Creed Aventus is the better fragrance overall. It has a greater depth and more little facets of different aromas than does Club. It’s the original, has higher quality, and slightly better performance.

However, if I were in the market for Aventus and didn’t want to spend $200-400+ (or whatever the latest pricing is), Club de Nuit Intense from Armaf would be an option, that I’d probably go with.

It gives you much of what you’d get from the Creed in terms of smell. Really, only some minor details are missing, but you save so much money.

If you’re going based on smell alone, I still like the Creed more. Is it that much better, to justify the price for most people?

No, for the vast majority of guys, the cheaper Armaf will do the job just fine. There’s a reason it has become so popular, even in a sea of other Aventus inspirations.

It’s a nice choice. Personally, I went with one of the Poseidon’s Elixir scents by Dua (there’s a ton of varients). It does a very close rendition of Aventus, even if I got the version with added berry notes. Dua is around the same price point at the Armaf, also.

Winner: Aventus

Who Should Buy Armaf Club de Nuit Intense EDP?

Buy Club de Nuit Intense EDP if you want an Aventus-style fragrance without paying Creed prices. It is fruity, smoky, woody, strong, and versatile. It works well for casual wear, dressed-up situations, spring, autumn, and most cooler or mild weather. It is the better value pick for most guys.

Who Should Buy Creed Aventus?

Buy Creed Aventus if you want the original and better-quality fragrance. It has better balance, more depth, a nicer birch note, and a more refined overall scent. It is the better choice if you care more about quality and scent detail than saving money.

FAQ: Armaf Club de Nuit Intense vs Creed Aventus

Is Club de Nuit Intense better than Aventus?

No. Creed Aventus is better overall, but Club de Nuit Intense EDP is much better from a value perspective.

Does Club de Nuit Intense smell like Aventus?

Yes, but not exactly the same. Club de Nuit Intense EDP is clearly inspired by Aventus and gives you a similar fruity, smoky, woody scent profile.

Which lasts longer, Club de Nuit Intense or Aventus?

Aventus lasts a little longer and is more consistent. Club de Nuit Intense EDP lasts around 7-9 hours, while Aventus can last around 7-10 hours.

Which projects better, Club de Nuit Intense or Aventus?

Projection is basically a tie. Both fragrances start strong and project above average during the wear.

Is Creed Aventus worth the higher price?

Aventus is worth it if you want the original, better balance, and higher quality. For most guys, Club de Nuit Intense EDP gives enough of the same style at a much lower price.

Which one smells more natural?

Creed Aventus smells more natural and refined. Club de Nuit Intense EDP is very good, but it does not have the same depth or quality.

Which one is better for compliments?

Both can get compliments. Club de Nuit Intense EDP may be the better value compliment-getter, while Aventus smells more polished and higher quality.

Which one is better for daily wear?

Both work well for daily wear. Club de Nuit Intense EDP is easier to justify as a daily scent because it costs much less.

Is Club de Nuit Intense EDP better than the EDT?

The EDP is generally smoother than the EDT and has more apple in the opening. It is the better option if you want a less harsh version of the Club de Nuit Intense style.

Should I buy Club de Nuit Intense or Aventus?

Buy Aventus if you want the best scent and do not mind the price. Buy Club de Nuit Intense EDP if you want a similar style for much less money.

Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT vs EDP

by

Chanel’s Chance line has spawned plenty of best sellers. Eau Tendre is among them, which has spun off two such perfumes in the Eau de Toilette and eau de parfum versions.

The questions then become, which one do you go with? What are the differences? Which smells better? Below is my take on the topic, after having tested out each of these Chanel’s.

Quick Overview

My Verdict

Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT is the better pick for me. The performance and versatility are basically the same between the two, so the decision comes down to scent preference.

The EDT is fresher, more citrusy, and has a powdery floral touch from hyacinth and iris. The EDP is still nice, but its rose and jasmine direction does not beat the brighter EDT.

Category Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP Winner
Opening Starts with grapefruit and quince, with the citrus lasting longer. Cedar, hyacinth, iris, jasmine, and musk give it a fresher and slightly powdery feel. Opens with grapefruit and quince, but shifts faster into jasmine, rose, and musk. The citrus takes more of a backseat. Eau Tendre EDT
Projection Projects above average during the first few hours, then settles into a more moderate scent trail. Projects about the same as the EDT, with no clear advantage despite the higher concentration. Tie
Longevity Lasts around 6-8 hours, usually more than 7 hours depending on the day. Also lasts around 6-8 hours, with no major increase over the EDT. Tie
Versatility Best for spring and summer, daily wear, office use, class, and moderate to warm temperatures. Also best for spring and summer, daily wear, office use, class, and easy casual wear. Tie
Overall Scent Fresher, more citrusy, and slightly powdery from hyacinth and iris. The preferred option if you want the brighter Eau Tendre style. More floral, with rose and jasmine standing out more. Better if you want less citrus and more floral softness. Eau Tendre EDT

Tale of the Tape: Eau Tendre EDP vs EDT

Chance Eau Tendre EDP

Notes include: rose, jasmine, grapefruit, quince, musk

eau tendre review

Chance Eau Tendre EDT

Notes include: jasmine, grapefruit, hyacinth, musk, quince, iris, musk, cedar, amber

Read my review: Eau Tendre EDT

eau tendre edt review

Opening

Eau Tendre EDP starts off with a quick blast of its citrus fruits, consisting of the same grapefruit and quince as the eau de toilette.

On my skin, the shift to the florals comes on rather fast. Jasmine and the rose note will come out with the usual musky base. But, the musk here isn’t as noticeable. Early on, the jasmine will have the upper hand. Then, the rose will be stronger.

The citrus doesn’t fade away completely, but it will take a backseat. There also smells like there is some cedar, in here, as in the EDT version.

Meanwhile, the EDT starts with the citrus notes. They stick around longer, than in the eau de parfum. This time they are joined by a more prominent cedar note, giving it a fresh aroma.

The floral notes are the hyacinth, iris, and jasmine. Hyacinth dominates and the other two split duties. There’s a fresher and a powdery kind of vibe coming from EDT.

Which is better? Obviously, there’s a lot of overlap, so they can come across as extremely similar at times. But, I think the floral notes provide enough of a difference. Personally, I like the EDT ingredients more so than the EDP.

Edge: EDT

Projection

You might expect that the EDP has a greater sillage with its higher concentration levels. But, if it does, I haven’t noticed it.

Testing these two out, the seem about the same. I’ve sprayed them on skin and t-shirts around my house and don’t pick up a difference.

That being said, they’re both above average. Especially during the first few hours of wear, their is a good scent trail produced with each and these perfumes do project well off of the skin. After that, more moderation, but each of them is about equal to the other.

Edge: Push

Longevity

The longevity here is also pretty much the same. With both of them, I will get 6-8 hours on the skin, depending on the day.

Most of the time, it will be more than 7 hours, but I have gotten each quitting before then. However, comparing the two, they are equal.

Even with the higher concentration in the eau de parfum, it doesn’t last any longer for me when I’ve tested these out.

Edge: Push

Versatility

Both of these are built for the spring and summer months, mostly. I’d keep it to moderate and above temperatures.

Within that, they are highly versatile with easy use as daily wear perfumes, whether that be the office or class.

Neither is much of a nightlife scent. It’s light enough to fit into most environments, without demanding too much attention. Plus, with the two Eau Tendre fragrances, they can easily be worn by any age group without feeling too juvenile or too stuffy on either end of the spectrum.

But, there really isn’t a difference with their use cases. Another tie.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

So, this is one of those comparisons that can be difficult to distinguish, since they are so intertwined with their ingredients.

The performance, use case, and overall aroma are essentially the same in so many ways. It really comes down to the floral notes and use of citrus in the composition, and which that you personally prefer.

If you want a more floral fragrance with the rose and jasmine, less citrus, and cedar stripped down. Then, the eau de parfum will be the choice.

If you want something that is fresher, uses more citrus, and has powdery hints from hyacinth and iris…the EDT is for you.

Those are going to be the main differences with each. Rose and jasmine or jasmine, hyacinth, and iris?

Again, I like the EDT slightly more for those reasons. It’s not a huge gap there, but since it’s equal in performance to the eau de parfum, it gets the overall win for me.

Winner: Eau Tendre EDT

Who Should Buy Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT?

Buy Eau Tendre EDT if you want the fresher and brighter version. It is better if you like grapefruit, quince, cedar, hyacinth, iris, jasmine, and a slightly powdery feel. It works well for spring, summer, daily wear, the office, class, and easy daytime use.

Who Should Buy Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP?

Buy Eau Tendre EDP if you want the more floral version. It is better if you prefer rose, jasmine, musk, softer citrus, and a smoother floral profile. It works in the same situations as the EDT, but it leans less citrusy and more rose-jasmine focused.

FAQ: Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT vs EDP

Which is better, Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT or EDP?

Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT is better overall in this comparison. The two perform about the same, but the EDT has the better opening and fresher overall scent.

Does Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP last longer than the EDT?

No major difference showed up in testing. Both the EDT and EDP last around 6-8 hours.

What is the Best Chanel Chance perfume?

For me, it is Chane Eau Tendre EDT. Not only do I like it more than the eau de parfum version, I also think that it’s better than Chanel Chance.

Does Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP project better than the EDT?

No. Projection is basically tied. Both project well during the first few hours and then become more moderate.

Which one smells fresher?

Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT smells fresher. It keeps the citrus around longer and has a cleaner, brighter, slightly powdery feel.

Which one is more floral?

Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP is more floral. It shifts faster into jasmine and rose, while the citrus takes more of a backseat.

Which one is better for spring and summer?

Both work well in spring and summer. The EDT gets the edge if you want the fresher and more citrusy option.

Which one is better for daily wear?

Both are great for daily wear. They are light, versatile, easy to wear, and work well for the office, class, or casual daytime use.

Is Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT powdery?

Yes, it has a slight powdery feel from the hyacinth and iris. It is still fresh and citrusy, not overly powdery.

Is Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDP worth buying?

Yes, the EDP is worth buying if you prefer rose and jasmine over citrus and powdery florals. It is not the winner here, but it is still a good fragrance.

Should I buy Chanel Chance Eau Tendre EDT or EDP?

Buy the EDT if you want fresher citrus and a brighter scent. Buy the EDP if you want a softer, more floral rose and jasmine version. Again, I think the EDT is the better formulation.

Stronger With You vs. The One EDP

by

Stronger With You from Emporio Armani and The One by D&G are two of the more popular fragrances out there for men. With a somewhat similar style, they can often be the final two options that people are choosing between. However, which one actually smells better? Lasts longer? Is the better buy, in comparison?

Quick Overview

My Verdict

Dolce & Gabbana The One EDP is the better-smelling fragrance. Stronger With You wins projection and longevity, but The One EDP has the better opening and overall scent.

The performance issues are real, but they can be overstated. If I had to pick one based on smell, I would choose The One EDP.

Here’s an alternative to SWY that is cheaper, if you wanted to just get both: Stronger with Dua

Category Emporio Armani Stronger With You Dolce & Gabbana The One EDP Winner
Opening Starts with cardamom, pink pepper, sage, and mint, with chestnut and vanilla underneath. It takes a while to reach its best stage. Opens with grapefruit, cardamom, basil, coriander, amber, and tobacco. It starts strong and stays appealing. The One EDP
Projection Projects better and leaves a longer-lasting scent trail. It stays noticeable after The One has quieted down. Creates a more intimate bubble and becomes softer faster than Stronger With You. Stronger With You
Longevity Lasts at least 9 hours and can reach around 11 hours. It is clearly the stronger performer. Usually lasts 4-5 hours with normal sprays, or 6-8 hours with heavier application. Stronger With You
Versatility Best for autumn, winter, cooler spring or summer nights, romantic wear, nightlife, casual use, and semi-formal settings. Also best for autumn, winter, cooler spring or summer nights, romantic wear, nightlife, casual use, and semi-formal settings. Tie
Overall Scent The dry down is nice when the chestnut and vanilla take over, but the opening is the weaker point. One of the best smelling popular men’s fragrances, with warm amber, tobacco, spice, grapefruit, and smooth sweetness. The One EDP

Tale of the Tape: Stronger With You vs. The One EDP

The One EDP

Notes include: grapefruit, basil, coriander, amber, tobacco, ginger, cardamom, orange blossom, and cedar

Click here to try: The One EDP

My Full Review The One EDP

the one edp review

Stronger With You

Notes include: vanilla, mint, cardamom, chestnut, amber, pink pepper, sage, violet leaf

Click here to try: Emporio Armani Stronger With You for Men Eau de Toilette Spray, 1.7 oz

My Full Review: Stronger With You

Opening

Stronger with You gives me a blast of cardamom up top, along with its other fresh and spicier notes. Pink pepper, sage, and mint. These are the leaders early on.

The undercurrent to this is the chestnut and vanilla notes, which really take over a bit later, but still have enough of a presence to make a noticeable impact at this point.

The One EDP will start off very much like the EDT version, but with some amped up notes. The grapefruit here plays a big role, along with the spice notes of: cardamom, basil, and coriander. All of which are soaking in a sea of warm amber.

The tobacco is also here, with its presence felt from the very start, and it will increase its role as we move along in the wear.

Which is better? To me, Stronger With You takes a while to really get going and into its best period. The opening is the weakest point, sort of jumbled.

Meanwhile, The One starts out great and continues pace. As such, it takes this category.

Edge: The One

Projection

Following the initial spray, these two actually aren’t far off from one another. Stronger With You does have the better ability to project, but it isn’t by much. The scent trail is longer lasting and it’ll project further off of the skin.

The duration of the sillage is where the real separation comes in. The One is already the weaker scent, at the peak of each fragrance. But, it quiets down much faster too. It’ll create an intimate bubble, while Stronger With You is still powerful.

Edge: Stronger

Longevity

Stronger With You also pretty easily takes this part of the contest, as well. It’ll last at least 9 hours and can go somewhere around 11 or thereabouts. It’s a very good performing scent on skin.

With The One EDP, normal sprays will get me about 4-5 hours of wear. With heavy sprays, I can go 6+ hours and up to about 8.

Heavy spraying is the name of the game with The One. But, doing so will get you fairly close to the Armani…Stronger still wins, however.

Edge: Stronger

Versatility

As far as when and how each should be worn, they’re basically the same.

Seasonally, autumn and winter, mainly. But, I will still wear them in spring and summer, if it isn’t too hot and humid. Though, it is mostly an indoor only option with air conditioning going.

You can wear them in a variety of situations, appropriate for a wide array of ages, but skew younger while not being something only teenagers can wear.

Romantic wear, nightlife, casual, and semi-formal.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

So, overall, which one of these fragrances to I prefer?

I’m not a huge fan of Stronger With You EDT. The opening act, isn’t all that great, in my opinion. However, the dry down when the chestnut and vanilla get to shine is actually very nice.

In terms of performance, it is for sure at least a notch above The One. Has better sillage for longer and even when the are both in their lighter stages, Stronger just keeps going on.

But, in terms of smell and which one I actually own, it’s The One EDP. Any performance problems, while not being without some truth, are pretty overblown. I wear it often, no real issues on that front.

Frankly, The One is among the best smelling of the best sellers in the men’s fragrance space and the one I’m going with here.

Stronger With You Intensely  or Absolutely would have a better case here, but even then, I still like the Dolce fragrance more. That being said, if you’re leaning towards Stronger, I’d get Intensely (I prefer this one) or Absolutely before the EDT original.

Again, The Dua Brand has their own inexpensive take on this style of scent called: Stronger with Dua

Winner: The One

Who Should Buy Emporio Armani Stronger With You?

Buy Stronger With You if performance matters most. It projects better, lasts much longer, and has a nice chestnut and vanilla dry down. It is best for guys who want a sweet, warm, youthful fragrance for dates, nights out, autumn, winter, and cooler weather.

Who Should Buy Dolce & Gabbana The One EDP?

Buy The One EDP if you care more about scent quality than raw performance. It has a smoother and more attractive blend of grapefruit, amber, tobacco, cardamom, basil, coriander, and warm spice. It is best for romantic wear, nights out, casual use, semi-formal settings, and close encounters.

FAQ: The One or SWY

Does Stronger With You last longer than The One EDP?

Yes. Stronger With You can last at least 9 hours and sometimes around 11 hours. The One EDP usually lasts 4-5 hours with normal sprays, or 6-8 hours with heavier spraying.

Does Stronger With You project better than The One EDP?

Yes. Stronger With You projects better and leaves a longer-lasting scent trail. The One EDP is more intimate and becomes softer faster.

Which one smells better?

The One EDP smells better overall. Stronger With You has a nice dry down, but The One EDP has the better opening and more attractive scent profile.

Is The One EDP good for dates?

Yes. The One EDP is excellent for dates because it is warm, smooth, spicy, slightly sweet, and intimate. Its softer projection can actually work well in close settings.

Coach Platinum vs. Coach for Men Comparison

by

For this latest entry, in our recurring head to head cologne comparisons, we have two entries from Coach New York: Platinum vs. Coach for Men.

Which of these scents is the better option? I have tested out both, reviewed them, and will now match them up in various categories before declaring a winner. Which lasts longer? Which has the better smell? Which is the better buy?

Quick Overview

My Verdict

Coach Platinum is the better fragrance overall. Coach for Men has the better fruity opening, but it becomes too linear and does not perform well enough.

Platinum is not a huge upgrade, but it lasts longer, holds its strength better, and has the more enjoyable dry down with vanilla, leather, and sandalwood.

Category Coach for Men Coach Platinum Winner
Opening Opens with pear, kumquat, citrus, amber, light spices, and a bit of suede. The fruity opening is the highlight. Starts with pineapple, sage, juniper berries, and black pepper, before more vanilla and leather come through. Coach for Men
Projection Projects around 3-5 feet with a few sprays, but fades sooner. Projects about the same at its peak, but maintains its strength longer. Coach Platinum
Longevity Lasts around 5 hours, which is pretty mediocre for the price. Lasts around 6-7 hours and keeps better reach deeper into the wear. Coach Platinum
Versatility Very easy to wear, casual, work-friendly, and better suited for heat. Also very versatile, casual, and work-friendly, but better suited for nightlife. Tie
Overall Scent Nice and fruity at first, but fairly linear and not very powerful after the opening. Slightly better overall, with a more enjoyable vanilla, leather, and sandalwood dry down. Coach Platinum

Tale of the Tape: Coach for Men vs. Platinum

Coach for Men

Notes include: bergamot, kumquat, ambergris, pear, vetiver, suede, coriander, cardamom, geranium

Click here to try: Coach New York Eau de Toilette Spray For Men, 3.3 Fl Oz

My full review: Coach for Men

Coach Platinum

Notes include: vanilla, sage, sandalwood, pineapple, leather, patchouli, black pepper, geranium, juniper berries

Click here to try: Coach New York Platinum Cologne for Men 3.3 fl.Oz Eau De Parfum Spray

My Review: Coach Platinum

Opening

Coach for Men opens with a blend of fruit notes: pear, kumquat, and other citrus ingredients. This top is surrounded by amber and some light spices.

The pear note leads the way, but the other fruit ingredients are quite nice, and there’s a bit of suede hanging out underneath.

Coach Platinum starts off with pineapple, sage, juniper berries, and black pepper. The pineapple is great at the start, but it goes rather quickly.

Then, really the juniper and spices, are in control with an ever increasing amount of vanilla with some leather.

Which smells better? Both start off nicely, though, I think I prefer the fruits in Coach for Men. The citrus in that fragrance, is just better than what I get up top, from Platinum.

Coach for Men really utilizes those fruity notes well and is the highlight of the wear.

Edge: Coach for Men

Projection

Both are about the same, in terms of sillage. I get projection from about 3-5 feet from both, with a few sprays.

However, Platinum seems to maintain its strength for a longer period of time. So, equal in terms of their maximum, but Platinum is more of a steady hand.

Edge: Platinum

Longevity

With Coach for Men, I only seem to be able to get 5 hours of wear, on my skin. My skin isn’t one to ‘eat’ fragrances, either. So, the performance, seems pretty mediocre.

Platinum will get me 6-7 hours, before it disappears completely. Plus, you still get the better reach, deeper into the wear.

Both of these aren’t that great, for the price that you’ll pay per bottle. Platinum, is at least somewhat passable.

Edge: Platinum

Versatility

Both are pretty versatile. Though, Coach for Men is better in the heat, in my opinion. Both can go casual, be something to wear to work, but Platinum is better suited for the nightlife versus Coach.

For everything else, these two are about the same. I don’t really see much of a clear edge here.

The strengths of these Coach colognes tend to be how mass appealing and easy to wear each of them is. Very pleasing, with a wide scope of opportunity to wear them.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

Coach for Men is a nice smelling scent. I do like the opening bit of this fragrance, as the blend of fruits, is both juicy and enticing.

If it had some power and some more depth, I’d be higher on it. However, it is a pretty linear fragrance, and one that doesn’t perform well.

Pretty much after the opening, you only really get a bit of coriander and cardamom. The fragrance is nice enough, but it never wows me.

Coach Platinum doesn’t ‘wow’ me, either. However, I think that it is the better of the two. Neither of these scents, is particularly unique, but the smell of Platinum is slightly better overall.

It’s sort of like Luna Rossa Carbon, with added vanilla and leather notes. I do enjoy the dry down, when it’s all about vanilla, leather, and sandalwood. That’s probably the most enjoyable part of the wear.

Platinum also has better performance and strength versus Coach for Men. It’s not way ahead of Coach for Men, but, Platinum is the winner in my book.

Winner: Coach Platinum

Who Should Buy Coach for Men?

Buy Coach for Men if you want the fresher, fruitier, and easier warm-weather option. It is best if you like pear, citrus, amber, suede, coriander, and cardamom. It works well for casual wear, office use, daytime situations, and hotter weather.

Who Should Buy Coach Platinum?

Buy Coach Platinum if you want the better overall choice. It has stronger performance, better longevity, and a more interesting dry down. It is best if you like vanilla, leather, sandalwood, pineapple, sage, black pepper, and a slightly darker casual scent.

Coach for Men FAQ

Which one smells sweeter?

Coach Platinum smells sweeter as it develops because of the vanilla. It also has leather and sandalwood in the dry down.

Is Coach for Men good for summer?

Yes. Coach for Men is the better hot-weather option because it is lighter, fruitier, and fresher.

Is Coach Platinum good for nights out?

Yes. Coach Platinum is better suited for nightlife than Coach for Men because it has more depth, sweetness, leather, and strength.

Which one is better for work?

Both can work for the office. Coach for Men is the safer daytime option, while Coach Platinum works if sprayed lightly.

Which one is more versatile?

Versatility is about even. Coach for Men is better in heat, while Coach Platinum is better for nightlife.

Should I buy Coach Platinum or Coach for Men?

Buy Coach Platinum if you want the better overall fragrance. Buy Coach for Men if you prefer a fresher fruity scent or need something easier for warm weather.

Light Blue Eau Intense vs. Dylan Blue

by

For this entry, I want to do a comparison post between two men’s colognes, with fairly aquatic compositions: Dylan Blue by Versace vs. Light Blue Eau Intense by D&G. Which of these two popular fragrances, smells better? Which has the better longevity and strength?

I have worn and reviewed each, over the past few years, and will now breakdown which one is the better buy.

Quick Overview

My Verdict

Light Blue Eau Intense is the better fragrance. Dylan Blue has the stronger projection, but Light Blue Eau Intense smells fresher, opens better, lasts longer, and is more enjoyable overall.

Dylan Blue is still a good citrus-aquatic fragrance, but the ambroxan, pepper, and violet leaf dry down is not as strong as its opening. Light Blue Eau Intense is colder, cleaner, and better for hot weather.

Category Versace Dylan Blue D&G Light Blue Eau Intense Winner
Opening Starts with bergamot, grapefruit, aquatic notes, ambroxan, and fig. The citrus aquatic opening is one of its best parts. Opens with frozen grapefruit, mandarin, juniper, and aquatic notes. It is colder, fresher, and more refreshing. Light Blue Eau Intense
Projection Starts stronger and reaches a higher projection level early in the wear. Can also be strong at first, but does not hit quite the same projection level as Dylan Blue. Dylan Blue
Longevity Lasts around 6-7 hours, which is decent and serviceable. Can last around 9 hours, giving it the clear advantage in staying power. Light Blue Eau Intense
Versatility Great for spring and summer, but can work year round. Useful for casual wear, dates, and dressed-up situations. Also great for spring and summer, but can work year round. Easy to wear casually, dressed up, or on dates. Tie
Overall Scent A good citrus aquatic scent, but the dry down leans more into ambroxan, pepper, and violet leaf. Fresher, colder, more aquatic, longer lasting, and better overall. The chilled fruit, aquatic accord, juniper, and woody base make it more enjoyable. Light Blue Eau Intense

Tale of the Tape

Dylan Blue

Notes include: black pepper, violet leaf, grapefruit, bergamot, tonka bean, ambrox, fig leaf

Click here to try: VERSACE Pour Homme Sealed Dylan Blue Eau de Toilette, 3.4 Ounce

Read my full review: Dylan Blue

Light Blue Eau Intense

Notes include: mandarin, frozen grapefruit, juniper, aquatic accord, amber woods, musk

Click here to try: Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue Intense Eau de Parfum Spray for Men, 1.6 Ounce

My review: Light Blue Eau Intense

Opening

Bergamot and grapefruit are the top notes of Dylan Blue. These two notes sit on top of a somewhat aquatic accord, surrounded by ambroxan, and a fig note which gives it some distinction versus other fragrances in this style. The opening is one of my favorite parts of Dylan Blue.

Light Blue Eau Intense also opens up with grapefruit, but is instead joined by mandarin orange, and the grapefruit has a frozen coolness added. It doesn’t have that same peppery intensity as the original, but I instead get plenty of juinper, and the aquatic accord in the beginning.

Which is better? I really enjoy how both of them start off, but I would say that I like Eau Intense more than Dylan Blue. It is refreshing and aquatic and doesn’t bring about similar thoughts of Sauvage, like Dylan Blue can.

Edge: Eau Intense

Projection

The sillage of both can be strong at first, but I think Dylan Blue hits a higher level. An hour or two into the wear, both of these colognes move more into the moderate end of things.

Edge: Dylan Blue

Longevity

Dylan Blue lasts for 6-7 hours on my skin and I never get any more than that. It’s decent and serviceable. Light Blue Eau Intense will last or 9 hours, in my experiences with it.

Edge: Eau Intense

Versatility

Both are great in the spring/summer, but can work year round. Both can go casual, more dressed, up and out on a date, if need be. I don’t really see much of a distinction between these fragrances, here.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

Dylan Blue grew to me having a higher esteem for the fragrance, the more I tested it out. I still don’t love it, but I do like the citrus aquatic opening, a whole lot.

The rest of the wear, becomes laden with ambroxan, pepper, and violet leaf. That part of it isn’t as good, but again, not terrible either. I never came around to thinking that the dry down, was more than decent.

Light Blue Eau Intense is better, in my opinion. The opening is even better than Dylan Blue’s which is the highlight of its life, and it also lasts longer.

It’s super fresh and the aquatic/fruit elements are chilled, which is really awesome on a hot day. Plus, the woody base with juniper floating around, only adds to its pleasant smell.

It’s a pretty close match up, but I’m going with the Dolce, in this one.

Winner: Eau Intense

Who Should Buy Versace Dylan Blue?

Buy Dylan Blue if you want the stronger projecting fragrance. It is best if you like grapefruit, bergamot, ambroxan, fig leaf, violet leaf, and pepper. It works well for casual wear, spring, summer, dates, and year-round use. It also makes sense if you want something more in the blue fragrance style.

Who Should Buy D&G Light Blue Eau Intense?

Buy Light Blue Eau Intense if you want the better summer fragrance. It is fresher, colder, longer lasting, and more aquatic than Dylan Blue. It is best if you like frozen grapefruit, mandarin, juniper, aquatic notes, musk, and amber woods. This is the better choice for hot days, vacations, casual wear, and warm-weather daily use.

FAQ: Light Blue Eau Intense vs Dylan Blue

Which is better, Light Blue Eau Intense or Dylan Blue?

Light Blue Eau Intense is better overall. It has the better opening, better longevity, and better overall scent, while Dylan Blue only wins projection.

Does Light Blue Eau Intense last longer than Dylan Blue?

Yes. Light Blue Eau Intense can last around 9 hours, while Dylan Blue usually lasts around 6-7 hours.

Does Dylan Blue project better than Light Blue Eau Intense?

Yes. Dylan Blue has the edge in projection, especially during the first part of the wear.

Which one smells fresher?

Light Blue Eau Intense smells fresher. It has a colder aquatic style with frozen grapefruit, mandarin, juniper, musk, and amber woods.

Which one is better for summer?

Light Blue Eau Intense is better for summer. It is colder, more refreshing, more aquatic, and performs well in hot weather.