kilian

Kilian Angels’ Share vs. Smoking Hot

by

Kilian’s Angels’ Share has been a best seller for years now and has been copied by a lot of different releases, trying to capitalize on that success. Meanwhile, Smoking Hot is one that’s gaining steam from the brand, but hasn’t gotten the same level of attention yet.

However, these two are often compared to one another. As such, I thought I’d do a post, matching them up. Which smells better? Lasts longer? And is the better buy?

Tale of the Tape: Angels’ Share vs. Smoking Hot

Angels’ Share

Notes include: cognac, tonka bean, oak wood, cinnamon, praline, vanilla, sandalwood

Click here to try: Angels’ Share at Sephora

Read my review: Angels’ Share by Kilian

Smoking Hot

Notes include: apple smoke, cinnamon, tobacco, Bourbon vanilla, moss, clary sage, licorice, Orcanox

Click here to try: Smoking Hot

My Review: Smoking Hot by Kilian

Opening

Angels’ Share starts of with its signature cognac, oak, and its tonka bean note. The cognac has an apple-like sweetness to it, which is fantastic.

The sweetness is enhanced by the inclusion of vanilla and praline. Which all plays well off of the spicy punch of the cinnamon note.

It’s a great mix of boozy, sweet, and spicy. Very warm with its aroma and has a baked good sort of undercurrent to the cognac-led mix.

Meanwhile, Smoking Hot also starts things off with an apple and cinnamon blend. But, it doesn’t strike me as being exactly like Angels’ Share. It smells much more like Apple Brandy on the rocks, just swapping out that brandy note for a smoky shisha.

But, there’s obviously going to be some sense of an overlap between them.

It’s fruity, sweet, smoky, a tad spicy, and fresh. The cinnamon note isn’t as powerful in Smoking Hot, as it is in Angels’ Share. Plus, you do get some moss and a faint clary sage note, adding a lighter and somewhat greenish dimension to this scent.

Vanilla, is also in the mix, but feels more prominent later on.

Which is better? It’s a close race. However, I still prefer the opening act of the cognac-soaked Angels’ Share more than Smoking Hot. Though, I really do like the latter a whole lot too.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Projection

Both of these fragrances have a strong opening act. I think Angels’ Share hits a higher high and its initial blast of notes is slower to fall off when compared to those of Smoking Hot.

Nonetheless, each of these Kilian perfumes is a strong, but not overwhelming fragrance. That will both settle into something more moderate, but still noticeable.

The performance differences between these two are interesting. Angels’ Share is the heavier of the two and has a bit better reach, in terms of its projection.

But, while it takes this category, the longevity is much more of a contest.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Longevity

With Angels’ Share, I get 9-13 hours of wear on my skin. It’s not a complete powerhouse throughout, but I for sure get a good and long time with this Kilian perfume whenever I wear it.

Smoking Hot actually matches Angels’ Share for me. Also, it has yet to not reach the 10 hour mark. 

I’ve been wearing each of them quite a lot recently. I haven’t noticed either of them really taking an edge in this category. So, I’ll call it a draw.

Edge: Push

Versatility

Seasonally, each of these are best in the autumn and wintertime. I think Smoking Hot is better than its competitor in slightly warmer temperatures, as it is somewhat lighter as a fragrance.

I wore it outside in 65 degree Fahrenheit weather and Smoking Hot was fine. I wouldn’t push it into summer, but it could venture somewhat into spring.

The smoky shisha aroma of Smoking Hot and the cognac of Angels’ Share may prevent them from being a daily wear for some people. The middle and latter stages of Angels’ Share isn’t too boozy.

It’s already a best-seller, so, I’m sure plenty of people wear that perfume to work without issue. With Smoking Hot, it does have a hookah smell. Take that into consideration.

Both are about equal in terms of casual wear and venturing into the nightlife. Not much separation here.

Edge: Push

Overall Scent

Overall, which of these Kilian fragrances do I prefer?

Both of these are great. However, I’m still leaning towards Angels’ Share.

I love the sweet mix and use of cognac in the blend. The rich oak and notes like praline coming through. A good cinnamon kick early. It’s a perfume that I’ve worn for multiple years and will continue doing so.

Smoking Hot is close to being as good, but just falls short. I like the apple smokiness early. That initial introduction isn’t long enough, I wish there were more time with that aspect.

The dry down of Smoking Hot is also very nice. I get some more woodiness, vanilla, and there’s a licorice note in here that seems more noticeable, later in the wear.

It’s one that I’m wearing a lot right now and may pick up a full bottle of. It’s a fragrance that is well worth trying. I just still prefer Angels’ Share in a head to head comparison.

If Angels’ Share is too sweet, feminine, or even boozy for you; Smoking Hot can be a great alternative. Still unisex, but seems to lean more masculine for most people.

Winner: Angels’ Share

By the Fireplace vs Angels’ Share

by

By the Fireplace by Maison Margiela and Angels’ Share by Kilian are two of the most popular unisex perfumes out there. As we are entering the colder months of the year in the northern hemisphere, I wanted to compare these two winter staples.

Which of these lasts longer? Smells better? Is ultimately the better buy?

Tale of the Tape: By the Fireplace vs. Angels’ Share

Angels Share

Notes include: cognac, tonka bean, oak wood, cinnamon, praline, vanilla, sandalwood

Click here to try: Angels’ Share at Sephora

Read my review: Angels’ Share by Kilian

By the Fireplace

Notes include: pink pepper, orange blossom, cloves, guaiac wood, chestnut, juniper, Peru balsam, vanilla, cashmeran

Click here to try: By the Fireplace

Opening

Angels’ Share starts of with its signature cognac, oak, and its tonka bean note. The cognac has an apple-like sweetness to it, which is fantastic.

The sweetness is enhanced by the inclusion of vanilla and praline. Which all plays well off of the spicy punch of the cinnamon note.

By the Fireplace, also goes spicy and sweet. The spice is more prominent early on, with the pink pepper and clove really punching through.

But, what separates it from Angels’ Share is the smokiness. The sweet roasted chestnut,  guaiac wood and juniper really come through. The Margiela fragrance certainly lives up to its name and theme.

Which is better?

These two are pretty close in the opening act. However, I personally like the booziness of the Kilian perfume more than Fireplace.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Projection

By the Fireplace does have a somewhat heavy feeling initially and a pretty far reach, along with that. For the first hour at least, it’s a strong-ish fragrance. After that, it’s pretty moderate the rest of the way.

Angels’ Share might hit a little bit more of a peak than does Fireplace. It also seems to have a slower decline with how it projects versus Fireplace. 

I do think the roasted chestnut and woods of the Margiela perfume, have a denser quality than Angels’ Share, though.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Longevity

With Angels’ Share, I get 9-13 hours of wear on my skin. It’s not a complete powerhouse throughout, but I for sure get a good and long time with this Kilian perfume whenever I wear it.

By the Fireplace is somewhere in the 7-9 hour range. Usually for me, it’s like seven or eight hours, but it can go a bit above that on occasion. 

This is a pretty easy win for the Kilian perfume.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Versatility

Seasonally, both are autumn and winter wears, all the way. They really do each shine in the colder weather.

Both are true unisex scents. 

An issue of each can be when to wear them. One is boozy and the other is smoky. Not what you might want to smell like at work. That being said, I think Angels’ Share would be fine in that environment, as it does have a sweeter and less-alcohol based aroma for much of the wear.

Either is fine for casual or going out at night. Pretty close contest, maybe not too much difference, but I’ll lean Angels’ Share.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Overall Scent

Overall, which of these fragrances do I prefer over the other? It’s actually a very tough call for me, as I own both, and really love both of them. As such, even when I pick one here, it is only a slight preference.

I like By the Fireplace a lot. Even if I don’t want to wear it all of the time. It’s usually one that I’ll wear at night during winter. Maybe not always going out, but just relaxing around the house.

It does everything well, the sweetness and smokiness are really pleasant. That being said, I think more people would enjoy the smell of Angels’ Share, as smoky perfumes aren’t everyone’s favorite.

I love wearing Angels’ Share. I tried the sample and almost immediately bought a full bottle of it, a few years back. It and Oajan are my two main sweet and spicy wears, when the temperature starts to drop.

So, Angels’ Share is my pick in this competition.

One thing that could potentially sway it for some, is the price differential. Angels’ Share is significantly more expensive than is By the Fireplace.

Again, while it’s a close call between them, if the budget was tight I would just get the Margiela fragrance and skip Angels’ Share.

Winner: Angels’ Share

Gold Knight by Kilian

by

Gold Knight is a fragrance sample that I’ve had sitting in a box for many months now. I tested it out a few times, but never got around to putting my thoughts about it down. Well, I essentially forgot about it for a while, and rediscovered it more recently. How does it smell? When should it be worn? Is it worth a try? Find out below.

What does Gold Knight Smell Like?

Notes include: anise, vanilla, bergamot, patchouli, honey, amber

My Full Review

The aroma of Gold Knight immediately reminds me of Opium Pour Homme, with that anise note up top. Vanilla, anise, and bergamot are here (in lieu of the black currant); along with a general warm amber thickness.

However, it’s definitely not the same as that YSL. Here, it actually is a sweeter honey/amber combination. The spice of the anise is flatter in Gold Knight and it lacks much of the balsamic and smoky notes of that fragrance.

To me, this Kilian is sort of like taking Opium and blending it with Grand Soir. The amber and vanilla notes are especially prominent, as this dries down and that’s basically what that Kurkdjian perfume is.

So, opening up you get a blend of spice and sweetness, both of which are tempered by that thick amber quality. The anise is nice and paired with a delicious honey note early on. Just a hint of the citrus and the opening act is quite attractive here.

The early stages are sweet with the anise giving things a nice added kick of spice. The bergamot hangs around for a little while, but will fade.

The anise also fades, just not entirely until later. This is when Gold Knight starts to really resemble Grand Soir, which I’m not that big of a fan of. Honeyed amber and vanilla with a touch a patchouli to dirty things up…which separates Gold Knight from that perfume.

That’s pretty much what I get for the rest of the wear.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

The sillage here is good, but not enormous on my skin. It’s pretty steady through most of the wear and I’d call it on the upper end of moderate.

The longevity is very good, even if Gold Knight isn’t entirely beast mode. As I’ve tested it out, Gold has stayed around for at least 9 hours and can venture into double digits. Now, those last hours are basically skin scent level, but very detectable.

Seasonally, this one for the autumn and winter months. It’s warmth, spice, and thicker constitution aren’t going to be great once the heat and humidity kicks in.

Gold Knight is listed as a fragrance for men. But, it’s actually quite unisex. Opium Pour Homme had more intensity and spice, that made it masculine. This is softer and easy to wear for anybody.

During that time frame, it’s safe to wear basically anywhere. It probably won’t lend itself to most high school students, but outside of that, it’s office safe. It can venture into the nightlife and be able to draw complements and not negative attention.

Overall Impressions of Gold Knight

Overall do I like Gold Knight? I do like it, but I also don’t want a full bottle of it. I like the similarities to Opium, which I used to wear a lot, but I still think that the YSL is a better scent. Plus, the back half here isn’t all that exciting.

Pleasant, sure. But, it doesn’t really do all that much for me. If you’re a fan of this kind of vanilla and amber (honey) combination, it could for sure be one to pick up.

The opening with the mix of anise spice and balanced sweet notes is worthwhile, I wish there were more of that or something else going on thereafter to really catch my attention.

The performance is good and it provides plenty of utility, as a versatile unisex perfume.

When I think of Gold Knight, the phrase ‘it’s fine’ comes to mind. Some people will absolutely love this stuff and it is generally highly rated.

To me, it’s a slightly worse version of a scent that I really did love at one point, and another that I never fully ‘got’. Kilian has better fragrances than this, but it’s also not among their worst. For the price, I do want something beyond what Gold Knight provides.

Apple Brandy on the Rocks by Kilian

by

Apple Brandy on the Rocks was a new release by Kilian Paris, that I really wanted to try ever since I first heard about it. Update: This post is from 2021, with some new additions. So, I ordered a sample to have as soon as I got back into town and have been testing this fragrance out. Does the Kilian Liquors perfume live up to the hype? How long does it last? Is it actually worth a buy?

Apple Brandy on the Rocks Overview

Notes include: cardamom, bergamot, ambroxan, apple, pineapple, cedar, rum, vanilla, and moss

Click here to try: Apple Brandy on the Rocks from Sephora

My Full Review

Here’s how Kilian describes this scent: Inspired by the city of New York, KILIAN PARIS introduces its new addition to the Liquors olfactive family: Apple Brandy on the Rocks, an olfactive soundtrack to nightlife’s liberation to come.

The opening to Apple Brandy on the Rocks doesn’t fully work for me. I’ve tested it multiple times on multiple days and still…meh.

There’s an aspect in here that I know I like, the apple and cardamom. However, the pineapple, bergamot, and ambroxan together are heavy and not very appealing.

Those do settle down and this Kilian fragrance will get better. After some more time passes, the apple not fully emerges which gives it a crisp finish, and I start to pick up more on the boozy rum note.

Apple, cardamom, rum are the keys to the second wave. Thankfully, that pineapple note pulls back. The ambroxan? It’s still around too much. It’s warm, slightly sweet, with a fresh coolness peaking through from apple and moss.

The next stage is apple and vanilla with woodsy notes, mostly. Oak, moss, and cedar sitting underneath apple and vanilla. The rum and cardamom, aren’t distinct any longer and provide a general warmth to the fresh woods.

It does simulate the apple brandy smell, well enough overall.

Sillage, Longevity, and Versatility

Sillage wise, I thought this one was going to be pretty powerful. The opening does hit strong and projects very well. That is short lived, however. Ultimately, it’s pretty moderate for a few hours. Then, it will sit close to the skin for the rest of the time.

The longevity isn’t great. I get somewhere in the 5-6 hour range, on my skin. That’s pretty bad for a Kilian perfume, as many others I enjoy will hit double digits.

It just doesn’t seem to want to stay around at all. That’s probably my biggest gripe with this one. I know it’s ‘fresher’ aspects can be short-lived, still rather disappointing for the price.

Seasonally, stick to autumn and winter. This is going to be at it’s best in colder temperatures. In the heat, the performance is much worse.

In the chilly air, Apple Brandy on the Rocks has its moments where it catches my attention. That being said, it does have a freshness to it that you might be able to sneak into the springtime, in many places. It’s not as ‘thick’ as Angels’ Share.

It’s a pretty casual fragrance that can be used for nightlife. Unisex for sure, probably leans a bit more towards the traditionally masculine side of the spectrum.

Daily wear too. But, I guess that depends on whether you can get away with smelling like apple brandy in your day to day life. Probably not the most office-friendly perfume for most people out there.

Overall Impressions of Apple Brandy on the Rocks

Overall, do I like this scent? It’s decent. I really like the original Apple Brandy by Kilian and was excited about this one, coming heavier with the fruit notes and freshness. But, ultimately it didn’t live up to expectations.

I was wondering if I was going to have to buy a full bottle of this, right after I did with Angels’ Share from the Liquors collection. Nope.

It’s not terrible and there are aspects that I enjoy. Mainly, the apple and cardamom when they are joined by the rum. The opening pineapple and ambroxan, I don’t like.

The dry down, with vanilla, woods, and moss added to apple and the remaining general warmth from the rum and cardamom is pretty good. It do get the comparisons with Legend, but they aren’t anywhere close to being the same, just have a few similarities.

So, even if the performance was awesome, I wouldn’t be inclined to get a bottle. The mediocre sillage and longevity, just compounds the reasons.

I don’t hate Apple Brandy on the Rocks. At this price range though, I do want something spectacular. To me, this just never hits that level. You may actually like it, but I don’t think it’s one to buy blind.

I did try a fragrance from the Dua Brand called, Blackberry Brandy. I know they have other fruit note brandy perfumes. That one is cheaper and quite good for this style of scent.

Perfume Comparison: Angels’ Share vs Oajan

by

Angels’ Share and Oajan are two fragrances which fulfill a distinct role in the winter months. That of the sweet and spicy perfume laden with cinnamon and highly attractive. However, since both are expensive to acquire and have so much overlap, they can often be the final two options that people need to decide between.

Well, on this page, I break down each of these unisex fragrances and compare them across categories. Which smells better? Lasts longer? Is the better buy?

Tale of the Tape: Angels’ Share vs Oajan

Angels’ Share

Notes include: cognac, tonka bean, oak, cinnamon, praline, vanilla, sandalwood

Click here to try: Angels’ Share at Sephora

Read my review: Angels’ Share by Kilian

Oajan

Notes include: tonka bean, cinnamon, honey, vanilla, benzoin, musk, labdanum, patchouli, and more

Click here to try: Parfums de Marly Oajan EDP Spray, 4.2 oz

My Full Review: Oajan

Opening

Oajan kicks off with the cinnamon note being joined by benzoin and the tonka bean. Add to that, the continuing emergence of the osmanthus note, which adds the fruity-like sweetness to the mix.

It’s a bold and spice heavy opening act. Fresh and dark, with a thick warmth from the honey beginning to come through after 5 minutes or so.

Angels’ Share starts of with its signature cognac, oak, and its tonka bean note. The cognac has an apple-like sweetness to it, which is great.

The sweetness is enhanced by the inclusion of vanilla and praline. Which all plays well off of the spicy punch of the cinnamon note.

Which is better? It’s actually a very close decision for me, as I really enjoy how both of these perfumes start off.

But, I might slightly lean towards Angels’ Share. It’s boozy sweetness is better balanced with its toned down cinnamon note. Oajan can be rather intense that way. Not a massive win for the Kilian, but it takes this category.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Projection

So, with older batches of Oajan, this would’ve been a fairly straightforward win for it.

Now, it’s closer to being a toss up. The opening act is stronger and heavier with the PdM scent versus Angels’. That projection still packs a punch. However, it doesn’t sustain it for as long as it used to before settling into something more in the upper moderate range.

Angels’ Share doesn’t start off as strong, but it’s also got itself a good reach. It too settles into an upper moderate level.

That being said, Oajan still has an edge with this one. Not as much as it used to, but it fends off the Kilian.

Edge: Oajan

Longevity

With Angels’ Share, I get 9-13 hours of wear on my skin. It’s a really good performer like most of these colder weather scents.

Older batches of Oajan used to last 11-12 hours for me. With my current bottle, it only seems to get to about 9 hours. Or, the lowest of what I get with the Kilian perfume. Those last few hours aren’t exactly strong, either.

So, Angels’ Share takes it, nowadays.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Versatility

Both of these are cold weather fragrances. Neither is for formal wear.

While each is technically unisex, Oajan leans more masculine, than actually being something that most women would reach for.

I wear each of these for casual to semi-formal situations. Lots of the time, it’s for nights out or when I just want something substantial and cozy to have on.

There’s not much distinction here, other than Angels’ Share being more of a unisex fragrance. So, I guess that I’ll give it the slight edge.

Edge: Angels’ Share

Overall Scent

Overall, which of these fragrances do I prefer?

Obviously, since I own bottles of each of them, I think that they’re both great scents. As such, it’s more like I’d choose one 6 times out of 10 versus the other.

I’d lean that fragrance being Angels’ Share. It’s not always my favorite between them, as sometimes I dislike the praline note and how it presents. But, that cognac is great with the oak and other sweetness.

I will say, for most men, Oajan might be the one to go with. It doesn’t have the same level of sustained sweetness as Angels’ Share, though, it definitely is sweet and has periods where that sticky honey note really pops.

Angels’ Share in its current form, just does most everything a bit better than Oajan in its newer releases. That might change again, at some point. For now, I’d opt for the boozy Kilian perfume.

Winner: Angels’ Share